Friday Fantasy: Cheating Death

Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #6: Cheating Death is a scenario for Goodman Games’ Dungeon Crawl Classics Role Playing Game and the sixth scenario for the Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar Boxed Set. Scenarios for Dungeon Crawl Classics tend be darker, grimmer, and even pulpier than traditional Dungeons & Dragons scenarios, even veering close to the Swords & Sorcery subgenre. Scenarios for the Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar Boxed Set are set in and around the City of the Black Toga, Lankhmar, the home to the adventures of Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser, the creation of author Fritz Leiber. The city is described as an urban jungle, rife with cutpurses and corruption, guilds and graft, temples and trouble, whores and wonders, and more. Under the cover the frequent fogs and smogs, the streets of the city are home to thieves, pickpockets, burglars, cutpurses, muggers, and anyone else who would skulk in the night! Which includes the Player Characters. And it is these roles which the Player Characters get to be in Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #6: Cheating Death, small time crooks trying to make a living and a name for themselves, but without attracting the attention of either the city constabulary or worse, the Thieves’ Guild! However, it is not the city constabulary the Thieves’ Guild whose attention they attract in this scenario, but Death itself!

Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #6; Cheating Death is designed for two to three Player Characters of First Level, but can be expanded to between four and six Player Characters and there is advice for increasing the difficulty of the adventure should the Judge want to run it for a group of higher Level Player Characters. It could be played through in a single session, but will probably take two. The set-up has the Player Characters either entering Lankhmar for the first time, or returning to the city, after a failed expedition out in the marshes beyond its walls. With some rooms sorted, at least temporarily, they retire to a tavern, where they can drink, carouse, and in the smoky din, pick up a rumour or two that perhaps will lead to a job or two and the chance to put some rilks in their pockets. Unfortunately, as they are looking for work, something—or someone—is looking for them. Somehow, they have attracted the attention of Death, the servant of the Lords of Necessity and unless they die, their names will unbalance his ledger. He stalks them, looking for moments when he can take their lives with a succession of accidents—trips on loose cobblestones, stairs collapse on them, gargoyles topping from roofs, crowds jostling them causing them, and more. First on the ordinary passersby around them, then on the Player Characters. They, however, will be initially unware of this, and his attention shifts from early warnings to deadly catastrophes and fatal attention, the Player Characters will need to follow up on some of the rumours they gathered earlier.

Following up on the rumours will lead the Player Characters to several locations and encounters, those around them suffering mishaps at first, and then they themselves, suffering increasingly deadly mishaps. These mishaps and catastrophes are tailored, at least in terms of damage to the three Classes in the Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar Boxed Set, but they are not designed to necessarily kill the Player Characters. Although deadly, the Player Characters have the advantage of Luck to keep them alive even as Death’s influence kills those around them. Not all of the encounters give much, or indeed any, information as to what is going on. Really, only one does, so it is entirely possible that the Player Characters could go straight to the last encounter, find out what is actually happening, and cut out the other scenes. What they will learn at this location, ‘The Leather Library’, from a sage is that Death is stalking them and that if they want to avoid Death, the best they can do is hunt down a local legend, the ‘Burned Man’, said to have escaped Death’s touch for years. If he can be found, then perhaps that would settle their account with Death?

The second part of Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #6: Cheating Death details ‘The Temple of the Burned Man’, which happens to be nearby and where the Burned Man has been lurking for decades—at the very least. His decrepit manse is laced with various traps and dangers, making getting to him difficult. The various locations around the manse are quite detailed and the Judge will need to pay close attention to how they work.

There is no denying that the premise of Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #6: Cheating Death, that of the Player Characters being stalked by Death, feels appropriate to the city of Lankhmar. Yet as executed, the scenario does not work as well as it could. To begin with, the scenario is too short and it feels just too random that the Player Characters could be targeted by Death. Further, the scenario can be even shorter than it is as written. If they go straight to the one location where they are can actually learn what is happening to them, they miss out on the other, admittedly small handful, of locations and encounters in which they have the opportunity to feel the effect of Death’s influence. This potential short-circuiting highlights the fact that scenario feels as if it should not be played out in one go, but its events eked out and inserted into other ongoing scenarios. This would enable the Player Characters to feel the effects of Death’s influence more readily as part of the story and have it upset their plans, to have it loom over them, and push them to investigate the cause. It would also enable the Judge to explore more fully a possibility suggested in the scenario, but left undeveloped, which is that the Player Characters might suspect something else to be the cause of their misfortune. The suggested cause—as came up in a playtest—was witchcraft, but others could also be added to enhance the paranoia of the players and their characters.

The other problem with Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #6: Cheating Death is the Level of the Player Characters it is designed for. As the sixth scenario released for Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar Boxed Set, it feels like a return to the beginning of the campaign set in Lankhmar. Now there is advice on increasing the difficulty of the scenario, but as a scenario for First Level Player Characters, it feels as it should be run between ‘Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #0: No Small Crimes in Lankhmar’ from the Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar Boxed Set and the excellent Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #1: Gang Lords of Lankhmar rather than later in a campaign. After all, which gang leader would not want to recruit a bunch of criminals who have cheated Death once into his gang? Also, this allow the legend of the Burned Man to be added earlier in the campaign and thus foreshadowed in time for when the Judge runs this scenario.

Physically, Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #6: Cheating Death is as decently presented as you would expect from Goodman Games. It is well written and the cartography is  decent.

Ultimately, Dungeon Crawl Classics Lankhmar #6: Cheating Death is too short to be a good scenario. It is not unplayable as written, but it wants to be pulled apart, developed that much bit further, and eased into an ongoing campaign rather than played all in one go, making its climax and potential reward just that bit more satisfying.