Every Week It's Wibbley-Wobbley Timey-Wimey Pookie-Reviewery...
Showing posts with label Satire. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Satire. Show all posts

Saturday, 11 July 2026

Convict Conscript Combat

It should be no surprise that the future is a corporate future despite our aspirations. So, governments and agencies might do all the scouting and exploration, but the corporations have the money to invest and they expect a return on that investment. In the Corealis System, the conglomerate known as the Corporate Echelon is attempting to squeeze as much profit from the system and that includes protecting their facilities, let alone the colonies. There are reports of bug infestations and scab pirates attacking ships and outposts. In response the Corporate Echelon has instructed its Military Foundation to find a cheap solution to the problem. The result is the Rehabilitation Incentive Program (R.I.P.), a programme of enforced conscription from the Corporate Echelon’s private prisons. Convicts are given basic training and sent off on relentless tours of duty. They will eradicate bug infestations, assault pirate bases and spaceships, conduct salvage missions, run supply missions, and more, but no matter the type and nature of the mission, the Convicts, known as ‘Dirtbags’, are expendable. However, if a Dirtbag survives long enough, there is the promise of freedom and reintegration.

This is the set-up for Dirtbags! A Sci-Fi Shooter RPG, published by The Dungeon’s Key following a successful Kickstarter campaign. Inspired by films such as Starship Troopers, Tank Girl, and Aliens, plus The Dirty Dozen and an unhealthy dose of the Borderlands video game franchise, it is a satire on corporate greed and capitalism and deals with a lot of mature themes. The dystopian satire starts with the look of the rulebook, which is heavily graffitied in a running commentary upon service in the Rehabilitation Incentive Program, the Convict Conscripts sticking two fingers up in punk attitude at the corporate commanders and masters.

To create a Convict Conscript, a player divides five points across three abilities—Bones, Cunning, and Nerves, rolls for his Convict Conscript’s Pardonable Offence and the Fallout, and then selects a role assignment, loadout, and trait. The Convict Conscript’s upbringing, personality trait, and appearance can all be rolled for. Each Convict Conscript also receives a fifty-credit signing bonus. The roles are Ape (Infantryman), Pill (Combat Medic), Tech (Combat Engineer), Hen (Reconnaissance), and Muscle Head (Support Gunner). Each provides three options in terms of Loadouts and Traits. Both the Pardonable Offence and the Fallout provide an extra bonus. In addition to his loadout, a Convict Conscript wears a Prisoner Identification Collar, which of course, is fitted with a small amount of explosives which can be detonated remotely, as a deterrent against escape attempts.

Name: Louise Kincy (MD)
Bones 1 Cunning 2 Nerves 2
Pardonable Offence: Medical Malpractice (75 years)
Fallout: High-Strung (No breathers in combat)
Role Assignment: Pill
Traits: Field Surgeon
Upbringing: Water Carrier in the circuit city sweatshops
Personality Trait: Petty
Appearance: Old World Prosthetic Hand
Loadout: 350-SI Service Pistol (three magazines), Surgery Kit, Juice Box Energisers (two), Tourniquet (one)

Mechanically, Dirtbags! uses a dice pool system. In fact, it uses three dice pools. These are Action, Ammunition, and Reserve. The Action pool is based on the Convict Conscript’s abilities. It is the number of dice that a player can assign to any one action. Using six-sided dice, any result of a four, five, or six is a success, although this range will increase or decrease depending upon if the Convict Conscript has Advantage, Disadvantage, or Severe Disadvantage. Any failed results go into the Convict Conscript’s Reserve where they cannot be used. Various traits will restore dice from the Reserve to the Action pool, but the primary means is to ‘Take a Breather’. Out of combat, this takes fifteen minutes, but in combat, it takes a whole turn in which the Convict Conscript can nothing else. A critical success, a roll of two sixes on an action will also restore a single die from the Reserve to the Action pool.

The number of actions that a Convict Conscript can undertake in a round is determined by his Ability values. For example, a Convict Conscript with a Bones of two has two physical actions in a round. So, his player might describe his actions in cleaning out a bug nest as first throwing a grenade at the hole out of which a bug swarm has erupted and then charging to its lip. Whilst a Convict Conscript with Cunning of two operating a drone might send it to hover over the hole and then scan for movement. In either case, the Convict Conscript’s player needs to roll a success for each action. Notably, none of the actions involve shooting or attacking. This is a free action. Nor does a player roll to hit. Instead, he rolls the Ammunition pool for his Convict Conscript’s weapon. The Convict Conscript can fire as many times as he wants. The only limits are the ammunition capacity of the weapon and its firing mode. Firing at targets beyond a weapon’s range reduces the number of Ammunition dice the player rolls. Every success is a hit, but if two ones are rolled, it means that the weapon has jammed. All dice rolled from Ammunition pool go into the Reserve pool and can only be refreshed when the Convict Conscript takes a turn to reload.

When hit, a Convict Conscript can defend using his Action pool or his Ammunition pool and every success negates a hit. Armour negates hits and can be destroyed. Damage is inflicted per location and if a hit location suffers two more points of damage, it is bleeding and will suffer more damage loss. Limbs can be ruined and amputated; if the torso is reduced to zero Hit Points, the Convict Conscript cannot ‘Take a Breather’, but can talk and still take free actions like shooting; and if a Convict Conscript’s Hit Points in his head are reduced to zero, he is dead. In addition to possible access to a Pill or Combat Medic, every Convict Conscript carries at least one ‘Muscular Intravenous Liquid Koka’ (M.I.L.K.) Energiser in his Prisoner Identification Collar. This can be automatically injected to negate hits of damage, ignore Ability limits, gain advantage on the Convict Conscript’s next roll, reroll any number of dice with disadvantage, and spend a success to gain an extra action. However, consume too many Energisers and a Convict Conscript can suffer an emotional outburst, such as hyperventilating, suffering a nervous breakdown, fleeing, and so on. Similarly, witnessing another Convict Conscript’s death, suffering an amputated limb, and other dire situation may also result in an emotional outburst. An emotional outburst is resisted with a Nerves roll.

Mechanically, Dirtbags! is simple and it does give a player plenty of freedom in terms of how and what his Convict Conscript does. Primarily this is because it removes the need to declare an attack as action and have it happen automatically if the player declares it. All the player has to do is roll for the effect. It means that the player can focus on his Convict Conscript moving and taking other actions. The limits are his Ability values and the size of his Action pool and the flow of the play is going to be from action to rest and back again from running and gunning and hiding and ducking to needing to ‘Take a Breather’ and back again. The Action pool and the Ammunition pool are both resources that need relatively careful handling.

Dirtbags! A Sci-Fi Shooter RPG is played out as a series of tours of duty, each of which consists of several operations, the number randomly determined reflecting the difficulty of a campaign. Effectively, length of play determines the campaign difficulty. A completed operation reduces a Convict Conscript’s sentence by five years and for every twenty years his sentence is reduced, he can improve an ability, take a Retinal Curriculum Projector course which grants a trait, or take a trait from his role. Between tours of duty, a Convict Conscript can take Shore Leave, which may be a relaxing time or it may leave the Convict Conscript without an internal organ, which reduces his torso’s Hit Points. The Convict Conscripts also have access to a wide range of military surplus that they can purchase and in return they can sell their military surplus and salvage. A sample mission, ‘Occam’s Razor’, a training mission that goes to hell with a bug invasion!

Dirtbags! A Sci-Fi Shooter RPG does not feel quite complete. There is background to the setting, but no advice for the Game Marshal and it could have done with a random mission generator at the very least. There is content sufficient to inspire the Game Marshal, but such a table would have been useful. It also does not address what happens if a Convict Conscript manages to reduce his sentence to zero, which is possible, but difficult after ten to fifteen operations. Whomever has amended the training manual that is Dirtbags! A Sci-Fi Shooter RPG calls it a return to slavery. The Corporate Echelon states that the Rehabilitation Incentive Program has an eighty percent success rate. One option here might be to look at Gangs of Titan City, a roleplaying game of criminal gangs and life in a spire city, as to what happens next, but otherwise, the Game Marshal is left to decide what happens next.

Physically, Dirtbags! A Sci-Fi Shooter RPG is a scrawling mess of a book and intentionally so. It is all punk attitude verses corporate bullshit and sometimes that does get in the way of what is relatively simple, straightforward roleplaying game. The example of play is actually the easiest and quickest means of learning the roleplaying game’s rules. The artwork is decent though.

Dirtbags! A Sci-Fi Shooter RPG has the potential to be manically chaotic fun, throwing it as it does a disparate, desperate group of poorly trained conscripts into one dangerous mission after another, whilst the Game Marshal throws every military movie cliché into the mix. It would be interesting to see what happens if the Convict Conscripts are actually rehabilitated, but that will have to wait for a supplement or another roleplaying game. In the meantime, the Dirtbags have one last chance to prove they are not scum in a light, but surprisingly detailed military Science Fiction shooter.

Friday, 1 May 2026

[Fanzine Focus XLII] Crawling Under A Broken Moon Issue No. 12

On the tail of Old School Renaissance has come another movement—the rise of the fanzine. Although the fanzine—a nonprofessional and nonofficial publication produced by fans of a particular cultural phenomenon, got its start in Science Fiction fandom, in the gaming hobby it first started with Chess and Diplomacy fanzines before finding fertile ground in the roleplaying hobby in the 1970s. Here these amateurish publications allowed the hobby a public space for two things. First, they were somewhere that the hobby could voice opinions and ideas that lay outside those of a game’s publisher. Second, in the Golden Age of roleplaying when the Dungeon Masters were expected to create their own settings and adventures, they also provided a rough and ready source of support for the game of your choice. Many also served as vehicles for the fanzine editor’s house campaign and thus they showed how another Dungeon Master and her group played said game. This would often change over time if a fanzine accepted submissions. Initially, fanzines were primarily dedicated to the big three RPGs of the 1970s—Dungeons & Dragons,RuneQuest, and Traveller—but fanzines have appeared dedicated to other RPGs since, some of which helped keep a game popular in the face of no official support.

Since 2008 with the publication of Fight On #1, the Old School Renaissance has had its own fanzines. The advantage of the Old School Renaissance is that the various Retroclones draw from the same source and thus one Dungeons & Dragons-style RPG is compatible with another. This means that the contents of one fanzine will compatible with the Retroclone that you already run and play even if not specifically written for it. Labyrinth Lord and Lamentations of the Flame Princess Weird Fantasy Roleplay have proved to be popular choices to base fanzines around, as has Swords & Wizardry. Another popular choice of system for fanzines, is Goodman Games’ Dungeon Crawl Classics Roleplaying Game, such as Crawl! and Crawling Under a Broken Moon. Some of these fanzines provide fantasy support for the Dungeon Crawl Classics Roleplaying Game, but others explore other genres for use with the Dungeon Crawl Classics Roleplaying Game. One such fanzine is the aforementioned Crawling Under A Broken Moon.

Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 12 was published in in January, 2016 by Shield of Faith Studios. It continued the detailing of post-apocalyptic setting of Umerica and Urth which had begun in Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 1, and would be continued in Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 2, which added further Classes, monsters, and weapons, Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 3, which provided the means to create Player Characters and gave them a Character Funnel to play, Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 4, which detailed several Patrons for the setting, whilst Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 5 explored one of the inspirations for the setting and fanzine, He-Man and the Masters of the Universe and Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 6 continued that trend with another inspiration, Mad Max. Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 7 continued the technical and vehicular themes of the previous issue, whilst also detailing a major metropolis of the setting. Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 8 and Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 9 were both a marked change in terms of content and style, together presenting an A to Z for the post-apocalyptic setting of Umerica and Urth. Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 10 switched back to more traditional content by focusing on monsters, whilst Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 11 examined some of the gods and patrons of Umerica and Urth.

Crawling Under A Broken Moon fanzine No. #12 continues the humour of the previous issue and puts satire right on the cover with the depiction of a clown-like server delivering a tray of fast food whilst wearing a badge that reads, “I HEART to serve man.” Which can be interpreted in many ways. Except not, because let us not dance around the issue—or rather, the theme of the issue. To cut to the chase, Crawling Under A Broken Moon fanzine No. #12 is the cannibal issue and Crawling Under A Broken Moon fanzine No. #12 is the fast food issue. Both of which are combined in a cannibal cult that is a parody of certain global fast food franchise. Subtle Crawling Under A Broken Moon fanzine No. #12 is not.

The issue also continues the examination of religion from the previous issue, because patrons know that at every branch of Buddy O’Burger, for a small donation, be served fresh,  tasty food by happy clowns and receive the word of the humour-filled gospel of Buddy O’Burger, the beneficent Burger god. So effectively, Buddy O’Burger is very minor cult with a lot of branches. Except that both the restaurants and the cult dedicated to the Burger god are a front. Where Buddy O’Burger, the beneficent Burger god appears dedicated to feasting and customer service, it is actually dedicated to feasting, customer service, and cannibalism! Most people accept the branches of Buddy O’Burger for what they are, but there are heretics and naysayers (otherwise known as food critics), who criticise both food and the cult. Often when a new branch of Buddy O’Burger opens up, they are the first to disappear.

As well as presenting the history of the cult from its founding to its current widespread status, the issue presents a handful of scenario hooks, amusingly listed under the ‘O’Burger Adventure Value Menu’. These include having to rescue a warlord’s children that have been harvested for the O’Burger value menu or having to defend against an O’Burger hit squad determined to stock up on meat. It is possible to play a Buddy O’Burger cultist in the form of ‘The Clownight’, who looks like he is wearing clown makeup, but has actually been transformed into a clown and been ‘blessed’ with all of a clown’s garish, bulbous features! ‘The Clownight’ has rubbery skin so gets an Armour Class bonus, a jaw filled with multiple rows of ever-sharpening, gnashing teeth for bite damage, and can gorge himself to temporarily enter food rage and gain an Attack Bonus Die. As Classes go, ‘The Clownight’ is definitely weird and creepy, and possibly too unsettling for some due to the high probability that the Class is a cannibal.

Buddy O’Burger himself gets the full Dungeon Crawl Classics treatment as a god in ‘Buddy O’Burger: the god clown patron’, which though replicates some description given earlier in the issue, does present some entertaining spells for his devotees. The Crave inflicts hunger on the caster’s opponents, Healing Feast summons a range of options from the O’Burger menu, and Meat Harvest opens a portal from the High Burger Temple through which giant gloved hands reach forth and grab the caster’s opponents for meat processing. The parody of the fast food franchise continues with ‘The Circus of Friends: The pantheon of the immortal servants of Buddy O’Burger’ including the Grumpus, a purplish, hippopotamus-like creature only placated by a frosty O’Burger milkshake, but is rumoured to mumble out prophecies that come true (which is why he is kept locked up by Buddy O’Burger in the High Burger Temple where he has his own agenda) and the Fry Filcher, a shadowy cloaked figure who steals french fries, but actually operates as a spy for Buddy O’Burger. Parallels between these servants and the other characters from that other fast food franchise are intentional, but given a sharp twist.

In between, ‘What is in that Jolly Meal box?’ gives a range of thematic, but minor artefacts such as Pocket Compass that always points to the nearest branch of O’Burger and collectable toys that give benefits if the owner eats at a O’Burger restaurant at least once a week, like being able to reroll a failed vehicle control roll once a week for the O’Krazy Kar toy. The inventiveness does not stop there, ‘The Delicious Artifacts of Doctor Dippinstein’ describing several artefacts in some detail. For example, each time a bite is taken out of The Double Death Deluxe Burger, it permanently increases the Stamina and Luck of the consumer, but several random creatures or persons within a mile drop dead. The consumer is aware of this. Eat blithely or at the peril of conscience…

The theme continues in ‘Twisted Menagerie’ with more fast food inspired monsters. The Clownug is a trusted servant of Buddy O’Burger which uses its clown-fun image to harvest ‘meat’ for processing, whilst the ‘Clownaut’ is the ultimate protector of the Buddy O’Burger, a giant clown. Lastly, the Fryder is a spider-like golem, searingly hot because it is made of fresh French fries. They hate all humanoids, but as you would expect, are very tasty once killed. Lastly, the issue ends with ‘Avatar Golems: The tools of the lesser mascot gods’, which gives the Judge the means to create lesser known mascots of the pre-cataclysm world and turn them into aspects of her own campaign world.

Physically, Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 12 is as serviceably presented and as a little rough around the edges as the other fanzines in the line. However, some of the artwork is better than in past issues, perhaps inspired by the theme of the issue and consumption of a Buddy O’Burger Jolly Meal box. Of course, the problem with Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 12 is that much of its contents have been represented to a more professional standard in the pages of The Umerican Survival Guide – Core Setting Guide, so it has been superseded by a cleaner, slicker presentation of the material.

Your reaction to Crawling Under A Broken Moon Fanzine Issue No. 12 is going to vary depending upon how you feel about clowns and cannibalism, let alone fast food. The contents in the issue are tasteless, even distasteful, but they are parody, adding a fresh and garnished meat patty of dark satire to the world of Umerica that is decidedly well done. Of course, the content  (though its tone may not) will work with other post apocalyptic roleplaying games and not just the Dungeon Crawl Classics Roleplaying Game or Mutant Crawl Classics Roleplaying Game – Triumph & Technology Won by Mutants & Magic.

Sunday, 26 April 2026

Therapy & Terror

What if the monsters today sent young men and women off on pointless wars of aggression and pride? What if the monsters today sat at their keyboards and spread hate and lies—and were even paid to do it? What if the monsters today printed or broadcast hate and division in the name of patriotism? What if the monsters today refused life improving and even life-saving medical care because it was deemed too expensive and people suffered because of it? What if the monsters today took hostages for political gain? What if the monsters today poisoned wells and befouled the waters because it was profitable? What if the monsters today were in positions of power and influence, what would happen to the monsters of old? The monsters from under the bed. The monsters from folktales. The monsters from legends. The monsters from just at the edge of the shadows? The monsters reduced to entertainment on screens big and small, in books on the bestseller lists? Would they even be monstrous at all? And if they cannot be monsters as they once were, what will they do?

In Mansters, you roleplay one of these monsters. Classic, even universal monsters. The Vampire, the Witch, the Werewolf, the Mummy, the Not-Frankenstein, the Ghost, the Zombie. Monsters who have lost what they once were, that is, scary, yet they still have the same powers for which they were known. Monsters who in attempting to understand why the world has changed and why humans are no longer scared of them, have lost part of what made them monstrous. And have thus become depressed at their loss of status and loss of opportunity to embrace their true, monstrous natures. Since they are trying to understand humans, they do what every human would do and that is to seek therapy. Fortunately, Doctor Lector runs Depressives Anonymous at which every monster can unburden himself and come to terms with the world that he finds himself in. He also finds an outlet for his monstrousness, seeking the evil men and women of the world and striking fear into them, to prove himself what he once was.

Mansters: Fight Against the Real Monsters of the World is a storytelling game, a satire upon horror stories and the modern political and financial worlds. Published following a successful Kickstarter campaign, it is from Black Lantern, the Greek publisher best known for the Soulmist, the post-apocalyptic setting of a world literally divided into two by darkness and light, written for use with Dungeons & Dragons, Fifth Edition. The aim of the Player Characters—or Monsters—in the game is restore balance in the world, both internally and externally. Externally, they want to return a sense of fear to the world, but keep themselves unknowable. There is a Veil between the ordinary world of humans and the world of Monsters, the Monsters living as ordinary humans on one side and unleashing, even revelling in, their monstrous nature on the other side. A Monster can draw upon his monstrous nature to achieve strange and arcane feats, but pierce that Veil too often and too readily, and a Doom may befall upon him. Internally, they want to understand humans better and restore their self-respect. So, they set out to stop those in power and control who spread fear, uncertainty, and hatred, and commit crimes that go unpunished, so that ultimately, humans will fear monsters.

A Monster in Mansters is first defined by his Abilities and Skills. There are three Abilities—Body, Mind, and Heart—and each Ability has four associated skills. Each Ability is represented by a circle, which is divided into four quarters, or Hacks, and each Hack into two Slices, so that an Ability has four Hacks and eight Slices. Similarly, each Skill can be divided into four Hacks and eight Slices. He will also have a Monster type—Ghost, Mummy, Not-Frankenstein, Vampire, Werewolf, Witch, or Zombie, a Charisma, and a Flaw, two more Banes, and a starting Monstrosity Level. The Charisma is the Monster’s positive quirk, ability, or power; the Flaw a negative, limiting trait; and Banes the aspects of the Monster which will impede him. Some Banes are mandatory, whilst the others a player can choose.

To create a Monster, a player selects a Monster type and then Charisma and a Flaw, two more Banes, and a starting Monstrosity Level. Each of his Abilities starts at two Hacks and he can then assign a further two Hacks. He then determines the number of Slices his Monster has in each Ability and assigns that number of Hacks to the four Skills associated with the Ability. The process is quick and simple.

Dirk Fordice
Type: The Ghost
Charisma: Mind Over Matter
Flaw: Incognito Window
Banes: It’s Cold Out There, Chatterbox

Body 2 (4) – Fight 1, Stealth 2, Shoot 0, Handle 1
Mind 3 (6) – Knowledge 1, Perception 2, Investigation 2, Politics 1
Heart 3 (6) – Manipulate 2, Insight 2, Intimidate 1, Streetwise 1

Mansters uses what it calls the Hack & Slice System. It makes clear that it is not a ‘hack & slash’ roleplaying game. To have his Monster undertake an action, a player will roll either a number of six-sided dice equal to the number of Hacks his Monster has in an Ability or the number of Hacks in an Ability and a Skill. The aim is to roll successes, that is, rolls of five or more. A Difficult task would require two successes for a Monster to succeed, whilst an ‘Are you insane?’ task would need four. To make a task easier, a player can spend Slices. A Slice spent from an Ability lowers the number of Successes required to succeed, whereas a Slice spent from a Skill a reroll of any dice that have not rolled Successes. A short rest will restore some, but not all Slices, whereas a long rest of several days under the care of Doctor Lector will restore them all.

Confrontations can be physical, mental, or social. They are opposed rolls, with the winner inflicting damage equal to number of Successes rolled more than the defender. Each point of damage inflicted removes one Slice, whether that is physical damage from Body, mental damage from Mind, and social damage from Heart. If a combatant rolls two Successes more than his opponent, he gains the Edge. This applies to both the Monster and the NPC, and gives limited narrative control to the combatant with the Edge. For the Monster, the plater decides what happens and for his opponent, the Doctor—as the Game Master is known—decides. If a roll is failed, it adds to the Monster’s ‘Skutendo’ clock.

When a Monster wants to use one of his Monster Superpowers, his player makes a Monstrosity roll. This is equal to the Monster’s Monstrosity Level. If the number of Successes rolled is equal to the Difficulty of the particular Monster Superpower, it is activated. However, this is not easy and it has consequences. A higher Monstrosity Level means that the roll is more likely to succeed, but a high Monstrosity Level will add even more to the Monster’s ‘Skutendo’ clock. A player can choose to lower the Difficulty by expending Ability Hacks, but this will lead to exhaustion if done too often. A player is thus forced to make a choice and as much as Monster strives for some kind of balance in game, there is no balance here. The consequence is to add to the Monster’s ‘Skutendo’ clock and also to the Doctor’s ‘D(oo)M’ Clock.

So what is Skutendo? It represents unlucky events that occur near the Monster, rolled randomly. For example, it could be ‘The Little Cousin’ in which the Monster’s aunt asks him to look after his cousin or a ‘Monster Movie Craze’ in which people start dressing up and acting as the monster, making it more difficult for him to intimidate anyone. It is triggered when the Monster’s ‘Skutendo’ clock is filled and then cleared again. When it is triggered it, it also adds to the ‘D(oo)M’ Clock. This tracks the likelihood of Hunters turning up to look for the Monsters, the Slices from the ‘D(oo)M’ Clock being spent by the Doctor to bring them into play.

They include the sibling monster hunters, the Losechester Sisters, Van Helsing, and Scrood-Be-U, a gang of monster hunters which travels in a van called the Misery Machine and whose members benefit from eating Scrood-be-Snacks. Antagonists in Mansters are talked about in terms of archetypes (as are the Player Characters). These consist of Mr. Moneybags, The Man in the High Chair, the Long Arm of the Law, the Underworld, and so on. These are supported by detailed examples, such as Elton Mask for the Mr. Moneybags. It is here in the naming references that Mansters best and most obviously shows its satire. There is some advice for the Doctor, but it is very light. There is, though, an introductory adventure in which the Monsters investigate a landlord who is evicting all of his tenants to turn a block of flats into short stays for Airbnb.

One issue with the scenario is that it does not fully showcase all of the roleplaying game’s mechanics since a Hunter is not intended to appear as the ‘D(oo)M’ Clock fills. This is disappointing, but it means that the Doctor can save Mansters’ Hunters for a scenario of her own. Oddly, it does introduce another mechanic, ‘Initiative Points’, which essentially tracks the effects of the Monsters’ actions and determines how well they have done at the conclusion. What this means is that it is not entirely the typical adventure the Doctor might expect as an introductory adventure for Mansters when it comes to showing the rules in action. This does not mean that the actual adventure itself is bad as it is otherwise enjoyable and nicely detailed. It also showcases how a typical adventure starts with the Monsters all attending Doctor Lector’s Depressives Anonymous sessions, which are as much social events as they are therapy sessions. Despite the name, the Doctor is not evil, but part of later therapy sessions will involve some reflection of the adventure or situation that just happened. These post-investigation/post-defeat the banality of evil session are also where the players expend Experience Points. This has the potential for some interesting roleplaying scenes if the Doctor and players want them.

Unfortunately, the rulebook does not list the experience point costs for improving the Monsters. Nor does it list the Monstrosity Levels for each type of Monsters. Nor does it really explore how a Monster’s Monstrosity Level goes up or down. In fact, only the Vampire has a Bane which can increase his Monstrosity Level. Instead, Experience Points are intended to be spent on permanently lowering the Difficulty of activating a Monster’s powers. Ultimately, it may be up to the Doctor to decide, depending upon a Monster’s actions, whether his Monstrosity Level goes up or down. Mansters should have explored this aspect of its design and developed mechanics for it.

Physically, Mansters is well presented. The artwork is fun, capturing the tedious normality of the Monsters’ lives versus their true nature. The writing could have been clearer in places and it is repetitive in others. The cover also suggests that monsters other than the ones given in the book can be played when that is not the case.

Mansters does come as a boxed set. In addition to the rulebook, the box also contains a set of dice, a deck of ‘Skutendo’ cards, Monster portfolios for each Monster type, and oddly, a set of Monster-themed coasters and a set of Monster-themed bookmarks! One advantage of the boxed set is that the Monster portfolios do give each Monster’s starting Monstrosity Level.

There can be no doubt that the intent of Mansters is good, a satire of classic monsters versus the banality of modern live and the banality of modern evil, and of old evil versus new evil. Unfortunately, Mansters does not quite achieve what aims for. Mansters can be played as is, but the lack of interplay with and of potential to shift the Mansters’ Monstrosity Levels means the roleplaying game’s intended imbalance between the Monsters’ everyday, humdrum human existence and their inhuman, monstrous nature cannot be explored as it really should.

Sunday, 3 August 2025

A Gourmet Gander

It was always feared that avian influenza—or bird flu—would be the one to get us. Despite numerous outbreaks over the past few decades, the world has been lucky. No worldwide bird flu pandemic. Instead, it was a coronavirus—COVID-19—that did for us, killing millions between 2019 and 2022, and forcing the world into a series of lockdowns that brought societies to a halt. In the world of Chew, it was bird flu that killed one hundred millions, including twenty-three million in the USA. In response the US government banned chicken and other poultry and like the War on Terror declared war on terrorism and sponsors of terrorism, declared war on all fowl. It poured billions of dollars into the funding of both the U.S. Food and Drug Agency (FDA) and the U.S. Dairy and Agriculture Administration (USDA), weaponizing both of them, and taking the FDA’s Special Crimes Division with investigating all food-related crimes, especially those connected to the farming, smuggling, and selling of chicken. Narcotics are not so much of a problem in the world of Chew, when there is more money to be made from dealing in chicken and terrorists with other issues will farm and smuggle them to fund their activities. Tony Chu, former Philadelphia police detective, is an agent for the FDA, not just a highly dedicated agent, but also a ‘cibopath’, which means he psychically reads the history of anything he bites—where it has been, who touched it, what is in it, and so on. It helps him with his investigations, but it also means that eating is not something he and others with his gift can enjoy. Chew is a sixty-issue comic published by Image Comics between 2009 and 2016 and the winner of numerous comic book awards during its run.

Chew: The Roleplaying Game, ‘A Foodie Crime Drama Roleplaying’, is the roleplaying adaptation published by Imagining Games following a successful Kickstarter campaign. It is a police procedural in which the core concept, best described as ‘Poultry Prohibition’, so think Elliot Ness, but with chickens, is the least weird thing about it. There is also cannibal crime, gourmet grievances, DNA dereliction, cockfighting capers, and a whole lot more. And when that is not enough, there is office politics, inter-agency rivalries, and the complicated home lives of the agents to deal with. Chew: The Roleplaying Game is a ‘Forged in the dark’ roleplaying game, meaning that it uses the rules first seen in Blades in the Dark and is a narrative roleplaying game with an emphasis on investigation. Its play is intended to be built around a ‘Conspiracy Board’, complete with different coloured sticky notes, connected, of course, by string, which the players and their characters can follow and amend to track their current case, combined with the use of Progress Clocks to track time, challenges, danger, and more.

The Player Characters are built around a set of Playbooks. These are ‘The Expert’, ‘The Hotshot’, ‘The Inspector’, ‘The Lowlife’, ‘The Mascot’, ‘The Prodigy’, ‘The Veteran’, and ‘The Wronged’. These are all derived from the comic book series. A Player Character has four attributes. These are Charm, Guts, Instinct, and Training, and they are rated between one and three. He also has three ‘Approaches’, traits representing physical or personality traits. These are all food-related. For example, ‘100% Raw’ means that the Player Character cannot tell a lie, whilst ‘Sunny Side Up’ means that you are always, always positive about life. These will affect the ‘Position’ and ‘Effect’ of any action a Player Character takes. Then there is the Player Character’s Quirk, his special power, like Tony Chu’s cibopathy. Suggestions include ‘USDAnimal’, a specially-trained cybernetic animal assigned to partner a USA special agent and serve as a Wi-Fi hotspot, being an actual cyborg, being a celebrity of some kind, having undergone some special training, and so on. Some are detailed, but players are allowed to create and name their own, with a table being provided for this. Perks represent a Player Character’s skills and are provided by the Playbook, whilst his Appetite Dice, refreshed at the start of each new case, can be spent to improve the action roll of any Player Character, to make a Resistance roll, to propose a flashback, or to grab an unscheduled break. Trouble will bring the Player Character intermittent difficulties, suggested categories including Debt, Family, Secret, Rivalry, Romance, and Vice. Over the long term, a Player Character can overcome his Trouble and ‘Stick a Fork in it’, but will then acquire a new Trouble. A Trouble has three dice of its own, which can be spent to reroll a failed Action roll, but means he automatically acquires a Condition and a worse Position.

Creating a Player Character involves choosing three Approaches, a Playbook, two Perks from the Playbook, detailing the Playbook’s Gear, and picking a Job. Three Attribute points are assigned in addition to the one provided by the Playbook. A Quirk is selected and lastly, a look is defined for the Player Character. Tables of Approaches and Quirks are provided that the player can choose from or roll on.

Our sample Player Character is Zillah Murgia, a scientist renowned for her study of the industrial properties of the hyperbolic paraboloid in age of food terrorism. Her brilliance is offset by an unpleasant manner instilled in her by an equally bitter, if not more so, mother, who to this day, claims that her daughter will amount to nothing, and a know-it-all attitude. At the age of fifty-four, Zillah still lives at home with her mother after a failed marriage, and to keep her mother happy, still wears what her mother suggests and gets her hair cut the same way. This does nor make her mother happy. After graduating from Harvard, Zillah attended graduate school. Unfortunately, her arrogance and unpleasantness antagonised the faculty and they attempted to persuade her to leave, which only made her more bitter and feeling further betrayed. Zillah typically found that a bowl of soup seemed to change the mind of whatever member of the faculty was sent to inform her and if that did not quite work, the hint afterwards that Zillah would go to H.R. seemed to solve the problem for her. After getting her PH.D., Zillah was asked to leave Harvard, but was quietly given a letter of recommendation, a pattern that has seen her bounce from one Ivy League college after another. Currently, she is permanent sabbatical from Dartmouth College where she has tenure and is working for the FDA to do something other spend more time with her mother.

Zillah Murgia
PLAYBOOK: The Expert
JOB: FDA Egghead

ATTRIBUTES
Charm 0 Guts 1 Instinct 1 Training 2

APPROACHES
Lemonhead – Cynical and leaves a sour taste in people’s mouths
Egg Head – Tried and True Nerd
Bitter – Holds a grudge

PERKS
Knowledge Bomb
Think Tank

QUIRKS
Donepulmentar – Onlookers lust after you when you slurp soup

GEAR
Tools of the Trade, A Goddamn PH.D., Portable Lab, Sat-Link, Tenure

LOOK
How your mother would dress as a Federal Agent

Mechanically, to have his character undertake an action or attempt to gather information, a player rolls a number of dice equal to the appropriate attribute, plus any bonus dice from special action or perks. The Gourmet Master sets the Position and Effect—abbreviated to ‘PEE’—for the Action Roll. The Position represents the Threat Level, ranging from zero and ‘No Risk’ to three and ‘Nuts’, and determines how many consequences a Player Character will suffer if the roll is failed. Whereas, the Effect level is the reward, ranging from zero or ‘None’ to three and ‘Great’. The Effect can be narrative or it can advance a Progress Clock. Only the highest result is counted. A roll of six is a success, a roll of four or five is a mixed result or a result with Consequences, and a roll of one, two, or three is a bad outcome. A critical roll is made if more than a single six is rolled, whilst a fumble occurs on a roll of one when the Position is ‘Nuts’. Consequences can result in complications, a worse position, lost opportunity, and/or Conditions. There are four Conditions and they apply directly to a Player Character’s Attributes. These will make a Player Character’s Position for an Action Roll worse and if a Player Characters all four, he suffers a Knock Out. Consequences can be withstood by making a Resistance Roll, which requires the expenditure of Appetite Dice, and if they are all used up, a Player Character will also suffer a Knock Out and Burnout, meaning he will also permanently lose one of his Appetite Die.

All of this is player-facing, that is, the players make the rolls rather the Gourmet Master. This applies to combat too, the NPCs acting as consequence of the rolls and decisions made by the players, and then the players making Action or Resistance in response. The players are encouraged to add to the narrative as much as the Gourmet Master—and use as much food-based terminology as they can when doing so, and whilst the rules look more complex than they actually are, they are quite straightforward. It also helps that the book includes plenty of examples, including a thirty-four page example of play.

Play and investigation of a Case is structured into three phases. These consist of ‘Off Duty’, where the Player Characters’ can be explored away from an active case or their jobs; ‘Investigation’ beginning with a briefing and then continuing with the search for the case’s three key details in an attempt to crack the case; and the ‘Action Phase’ where the perpetrators are caught or identified. The three phases are followed by a ‘Debriefing’, which can be both in game and out.

For the Gourmet Master there is a breakdown of a Case File and how to create one, backed up with a table of crime names and tables to generate random crimes, as well as advice on handling and resolving the investigation, handling conspiracies, unscheduled breaks, and more. All covering the game play’s core phases. The background covers both the FDA and USDA as employers of the Player Characters, and advice on how to portray their boss. Numerous factions are detailed and categorised according to the threat they pose to the Player Characters, from Tier I and limited influence to Tier V and possessing global influence. For example, a Tier I threat might be the Crime Alley Ramblers and the Philly Goths, whilst an Amazon Necromantic Death Cult and the Chicken Colonels are Tier II. All of these factions are nicely detailed, with their typical looks, possible Clocks, assets, notable NPCs, allies and enemies, and so on. Some eighty or so factions are detailed in this fashion. Various places of interest, again drawn from the comic book, are also detailed, including their first appearance, locations, notable details and reasons to go there, possible NPCs and scenes, and these together with the earlier descriptions of the main characters from the comic book and the multiple factions, the Chew: The Roleplaying Game serves as a decent sourcebook for the comic book.

Rounding out the Chew: The Roleplaying Game are two scenarios. This is in addition to a couple of case file descriptions slotted earlier into the book which could be adapted for play by the Gourmet Master. The first scenario is ‘Over an Open Flame’ by Banana Chan’ in which the Player Characters have to solve the kidnapping of reality television chefs to make them cook over an open volcano whilst in Bridgett Jefferies’ ‘Thigh Man, Thigh Man’, the Player Characters have to identify and track down the mysterious prankster who has been breaking into the homes of FDA agents and broadcasting from there. This offers the opportunity for the Gourmet Master to play lots of tricks and pranks on the Player Characters, increasingly frustrating them. The Player Characters are ‘Rogue Agents’, recognising something of the prankster’s escapades and in investigating and potentially capturing him, perhaps proving themselves to be FDA agents once again. Both scenarios are entertaining, both are spiced with food puns aplenty, and both coming with plenty of cooking tips, as the advice for Gourmet Master is called.

Physically, Chew: The Roleplaying Game is a frenzy of vibrant colour and action, liberally illustrated with artwork from the comic book, alongside what is actually quite a lot of text. In places it does feel dense and lean towards being overwritten, the numerous examples and the extended example of play very much serve to counter this. What this means is that Chew: The Roleplaying Game is actually a lot simpler than it first looks.

Chicken is kind of an everyman kind of food, a meat whose flavour and texture lends itself to a multitude of ingredients, herbs, and recipes, giving a great flexibility, whereas Chew: The Roleplaying Game is very much not that. It is specifically designed to handle the weird zaniness and wacky action depicted in the comic, a world of taco terrorism, food fears given form, alien invasive plants, cannibal crime, but definitely, definitely not vampires. Which means unlike the ubiquity of chicken, it is not a roleplaying game that is going to appeal to everyone and it definitely pays to have read the comics. Of course, fans of the comic will definitely want to get their teeth into Chew: The Roleplaying Game, and they will find generous servings of everything they enjoyed about Chew.

Tuesday, 31 December 2024

1984: Paranoia

1974 is an important year for the gaming hobby. It is the year that Dungeons & Dragons was introduced, the original RPG from which all other RPGs would ultimately be derived and the original RPG from which so many computer games would draw for their inspiration. It is fitting that the current owner of the game, Wizards of the Coast, released the new version, Dungeons & Dragons, Fifth Edition, in the year of the game’s fortieth anniversary, and the new edition of that, Dungeons & Dragons, 2024, in the year of the game’s fiftieth anniversary. To celebrate this, Reviews from R’lyeh will be running a series of reviews from the hobby’s anniversary years, thus there will be reviews from 1974, from 1984, from 1994, and from 2004—the thirtieth, twentieth, and tenth anniversaries of the titles. These will be retrospectives, in each case an opportunity to re-appraise interesting titles and true classics decades on from the year of their original release.

—oOo—

1984 produced two of the greatest roleplaying games designed in response to the Cold War and two of the greatest humour roleplaying games. One of the Cold War roleplaying games was Twilight 2000, whilst one of the humour roleplaying games was Toon. In both cases, the other roleplaying game was Paranoia. Published by West End Games, previously known for its wargames, Paranoia: A Role-Playing Game of a Darkly Humorous Future is a Science Fiction post-apocalyptic dystopian satire inspired by classics of the genre, such as Nineteen Eighty-Four, Brave New World, Logan’s Run, and THX 1138. It is both a satire on capitalism and communism, a roleplaying game of trust and distrust—mostly the latter, laced with black humour, drenched in irony, and if it was not the first roleplaying game that specifically pitted the players and their characters against one another, it was certainly, the roleplaying game to not only embrace it wholeheartedly, but also to actively encourage it. What it was though, was the first roleplaying game in which the Game Master was as much an adversary to the Player Characters as they were to each other, and it was the first roleplaying game in which knowledge or possession of the rules was punishable by death. The play and the setting of Paranoia is one of ignorance and fear built on a series of contradictions which the players and their characters attempt to navigate, rarely with any success, and generally, with consequences both disastrous and funny for all concerned.

The setting for Paranoia: A Role-Playing Game of a Darkly Humorous Future is Alpha Complex, a vast underground city where the last of humanity survives thanks to the protection and facilities provided by the Computer. The Computer is their friend. Citizens of Alpha Complex are decanted into Clone Families of six identical clones and raised to serve meaningful and satisfying lives in service to Alpha Complex and in return be provided with nutritious food and enjoyable entertainment. Most clones and their families possess a Security Clearance of Infrared. Depending upon the role and assignment of a Citizen, he may achieve a higher Security Clearance (if he is not executed first). This is based on the colour spectrum, so in ascending order is RED, ORANGE, YELLOW, GREEN, BLUE, INDIGO, VIOLET, and ULTRAVIOLET, the latter clearance only available to High Programmers and (on a temporary basis) Game Masters. Unfortunately, Alpha Complex is at war and has been ever since it was established. There are forces outside of Alpha Complex which want to see it and its way of life it provides its friends with destroyed. Worse though are those who would destroy it from within. First and foremost, Commies. Commies are Traitors. Commies are everywhere. Then there are Mutants and members of Secret Societies. Mutants and members of Secret Societies are Traitors. It is the duty of every Citizen of Alpha Complex to report all signs of treasonous activities, including being a Commie, a Mutant, or a Member of a Secret Society. Not reporting signs of treasonous activities, including being a Commie, a Mutant, or a Member of a Secret Society is treasonous.

Fortunately, Alpha Complex has a solution: Troubleshooters. Troubleshooters are carefully selected Infrared Clones trained and equipped to further serve the Computer, including spotting Traitors and signs of treason. To reflect their training, equipment, and responsibilities, they are promoted to RED Security Clearance level and assigned to a Service Group that can be the Armed Forces, Central Processing Unit, Housing Preservation & Development or Mind Control, Internal Security, Power Services, Production, Logistics, and Commissary, and Research & Design. Unfortunately, each Troubleshooter has a secret. He is a Traitor. He is a Traitor because he is a Member of a Secret Society. So, he has to keep this a secret. Unfortunately, each Troubleshooter has another secret. He is a Traitor. He is a Traitor because he is a Mutant. So, he has to keep this a secret. Guess which roles the players roleplay in Paranoia? And the good news is that in event of a Troubleshooter’s death, whether in the patriotic and glorious service of the Computer or because he has been identified as a Traitor and dutifully reported for Self-Termination, his current assignment and duties will be immediately undertaken by the next member of the Troubleshooter’s Clone Family, who is fully trusted by the Computer and is not a Traitor.

Paranoia: A Role-Playing Game of a Darkly Humorous Future was published as a boxed set. It contained three books and a pair of two twenty-sided dice, marked one to ten twice. The three books are the twenty-four-page ‘Player Handbook’, the sixty-four-page ‘Gamemaster Handbook’, and the fifty-two-page ‘Adventure Handbook’. Notably, the ‘Adventure Handbook’ is actually the scenario booklet and done as a then traditional module format and the page numbers actually run concurrently from the ‘Player Handbook’ through the ‘Gamemaster Handbook’ to the ‘Adventure Handbook’.

A Troubleshooter in Paranoia has eight primary attributes. These are Strength, Agility, Manual Dexterity, Endurance, Moxie, Chutzpah, Mechanical Aptitude, and Power Index. These are range in value between two and twenty, with Chutzpah being defined as, “…[T]he quality of a man who kills both his parents and then pleads for mercy because he is an orphan.”; Moxie as the ability to comprehend the unusual; and Power Index the strength of a Troubleshooter’s mutant power. He has a Mutant Power and belongs to both a Service Group and a Secret Society. He also has several skills, which are represented as percentages. Skills are organised into skill trees with the lower the skill is down a skill tree, the more specialised it is and the higher the skill bonus it grants. To create a Troubleshooter, a player rolls for everything bar the skills which he assigns points to with the few points a beginning Troubleshooter is given. He is given some mandatory equipment and 100 credits with which to purchase more. The skills are not written down on the Troubleshooter sheet as a list, but drawn as a skill tree.

Name: Budd-R-FLY-1
Clone Number: 1
Security Clearance: Red
Service Group: Research & Design
Secret Society: Spy for Armed Forces
Mutant Power: Extraordinary Power – Mental Blast
Commendation Points: 0
Treason Points: 0

Credit: 100

Strength 13 Agility 18 Manual Dexterity 14 Endurance 11
Moxie 06 Chutzpah 08 Mechanical Aptitude 13 Power Index 14
Carrying Capacity: 30 Damage Bonus: —
Macho Bonus: — Melee Bonus: +17%
Aimed Weapon Bonus: +07% Comprehension Bonus: -10%
Believability Bonus: -05% Repair Bonus: +04%

SKILLS
Basic Operations 1 (20%); Melee Combat 2 (25%); Aimed Combat 2 (25%)
Technical Services 1 (20%); Robotics 2 (25%)

EQUIPMENT
red reflec armour, laser pistol, laser barrel (red stripe), jump suit, utility belt & pouches, Com Unit I, knife, notebook & stylus

The ‘Player Handbook’ does not explain the rules to the game, because, after all, that requires ULTRAVIOLET Security Clearance, but it does have details of bookkeeping, how a typical mission works and how combat works, the etiquette to playing Paranoia, and so on. Bookkeeping involves the tracking of several types of points. Credits can be rewarded to spend on more equipment. Commendation Points are earned for completing missions, distinguished service, and eliminating Traitors and will go towards a Troubleshooter being promoted. Treason Points are earned by failing to follow or complete orders, doubting or acting or speaking against the Computer, being a member of a Secret Society or a Mutants, and so on, if at any time they exceed Commendation Points by ten or more, the Computer will issue a Termination Order for treason. Secret Society Points are earned for fulfilling a Secret Society’s aims and will reward a Troubleshooter with promotion and access to information, equipment, and help, some of which might be useful.

A typical mission will begin with a briefing from the Computer and the assignment of useful equipment that will want testing. A Troubleshooter may also receive a private briefing from the Computer, from Internal Security, or from his Service Group. However, because he is also a Traitor, he receive an additional private briefing from his Secret Society. Throughout the mission, a Troubleshooter is expected to root out and eliminate Traitors, complete the mission, and keep safe the lives of the Computer’s valuable agents (including himself). Actual play exacerbates all of the tensions that this sets up because Paranoia is a game of secrets. A Troubleshooter’s character sheet is a secret, the contents of the ‘Gamemaster Handbook’ are secret, and all of the notes passed and the private asides between the Game Master and her players are secret. Consequently, separation of player knowledge and Troubleshooter knowledge is a necessity and some cases, failure to separate the two is treasonous. For example, demonstrating knowledge of the ‘Gamemaster Handbook’ is treasonous. Further, in play, the Game Master is encouraged—and shown in an example of play—to watch and listen for player knowledge being expressed by his Troubleshooter. So, for example, when a Troubleshooter on a mission to the Outside calls the small fluffy humanoid with tiny arms and legs, a tiny nose, and a rearward facing, long and very fluffy arm without a visible hand a ‘squirrel’, the first question on the mind of Game Master as the Computer (and also on the mind of his fellow Troubleshooters), is how does the Troubleshooter know it is called a ‘squirrel’? Followed by, ‘Where did he get such treasonous knowledge?’ Even if the Troubleshooter is a member of the Sierra Club Secret Society and actually does know what a squirrel is, knowledge of what a squirrel is treasonous, as is, of course, being a member of a Secret Society.

Mechanically, the ‘Player Handbook’ does not teach the player the rules of Paranoia because he does not have sufficient Security Clearance. What it does do is show him with a solitaire adventure. It is short at fifty-four entries and three pages long, but it nicely demonstrates the tone and style of play in Paranoia. As the player reads through it, he will earn letter codes, each of which determines whether he has earned Commendation Points, Treason Points, and so on. It will not take a player very long to play through it, but it is short enough for a player to explore the untaken storylines within it to see the consequences of other actions. Doubtless, this is treasonous behaviour, but it gives a player an idea of what to expect.

The ‘Gamemaster Handbook’ does explain the background, setting, and rules to Paranoia. The background is quite slight, almost inconsequential given the post-apocalyptic nature of setting. The setting description covers everyday life in Alpha Complex, the Service Groups, Security Clearances, and so on. All seventeen of the Secret Societies are described—Anti-Mutant, Communists, Computer Phreaks, Corpore Metal, Death leopard, First Church of Christ Computer-Programmer, Frankenstein Destroyers, Free Enterprise, Humanists, Illuminati, Mystics, Pro Tech, Programs Group, Psion, Purge, Romantics, and Sierra Club. In addition, a Troubleshooter can also be a spy for another Service Group or even another Alpha Complex! In each case, their objectives, doctrines, friends, and enemies are listed along with a general description and means of advancement. Special rules cover what a Secret Group might actually teach a member if he survives long enough. Mutant Powers are given a similar treatment.

In terms of mechanics, Paranoia looks more complex than it actually is. The roleplaying game uses ten-sided dice. For an attribute check, a player rolls a number of ten-sided dice and attempts to roll equal to or less than the attribute to succeed. The difficulty is measured in terms of the number of dice a player has to roll, from one for Extremely easy to five for Outrageous. Otherwise, Paranoia is a percentile system and skill-based. The aim is to roll equal to, or lower, than the skill to succeed, with a Troubleshooter always having a minimum chance of success of 5%. A skill is modified by an appropriate Troubleshooter’s Attribute Modifier and by the circumstances. It is the latter where Paranoia does get more complex. The skill categories are described in some detail and there are a lot of modifiers, which vary from skill or skill, and can result in a skill rating being divided or multiplied or simply added to or detracted from.

When it comes to combat, the ‘Player Handbook’ states that it eschews the, “…[E]laborate movement and combat systems reflecting their ancestral wargame heritage.” of other roleplaying games and instead aims for a ‘dramatic tactical system’—“[A] sort of unsystem – to encourage fast and flamboyant action.” Thus, it was writing against what had come before in terms of roleplaying games and their combat systems and what West End Games, the publisher of Paranoia, was best known for doing at the time, which was wargames. It was wholly reliant upon the Game Master, as she, of course, had the Security Clearance to know how the rules—fully explained in the ‘Gamemaster Handbook’—worked, and today, the ‘dramatic tactical system’ of Paranoia would be best described as theatre of the mind style play, since it did not rely on maps or miniatures. (The irony here being that miniatures have since been released for subsequent editions of Paranoia.) Some of this is seen in how damage is handled in that a Troubleshooter does not have Hit Points, but weapons instead inflict effects such as stun, wound, incapacitate, kill, and so on. If combat is meant to be dramatic and exciting for all, there is still a set of combat mechanics that need to be learned by the Game Master. These are not complex, but the Game Master still needs to know them to apply them to the ‘dramatic tactical system’ that Paranoia wants her to run the game as and there are quite a lot of weapon special effects, such as the various ammunition types of slug throwers and cone rifles, ice guns, and tanglers, which she needs to be aware of. Not necessarily in every mission, but they are there in the rules.

Perhaps the most important section in the ‘Gamemaster Handbook’ is on ‘Gamemastering Paranoia’. This is because Paranoia was—and in some ways, still is—different to any other roleplaying game, certainly in comparison to the ones that came before it. The Game Master has many roles in Paranoia. Like any other roleplaying game, the first was to portray the world and act as the eyes and ears of the players and their characters. After that? All bets are off. The Game Master has to portray an NPC, the Computer that both cares about the Citizens of Alpha Complex and thus the Troubleshooter, and loves them. It even trusts them. It also does not trust them. It also fears that one of them, if not all of them are Traitors. It is a mass of contradictions that builds tension and distrust and instils fear and ignorance with the Game Master knowing everything and the players and their Troubleshooters knowing nothing. As a representative of a nasty, totalitarian enclosed society, the Game Master may not be actively trying to kill the Troubleshooters—though she very probably is—but she is definitely looking for reasons to kill the Troubleshooters.

The advice for running Paranoia is excellent throughout. It amounts to controlling information and rationing it with a miserly reluctance, killing the bastards, fighting dirty, accepting that sometimes situations are hopeless, and letting the players feel that bad luck or idiocy is responsible for their Troubleshooters’ fate, rather than maliciousness upon the part of the Game Master. Similarly, the advice for running combat is to keep things moving, never give the players and their Troubleshooters the time to think, reward flamboyance and strange ideas, to kill the bastards, and to really, really keep things moving. Topped by the fact that the Game Master should ‘Sound Impartial’, despite the fact that she probably being anything other than that. All of which is supported by examples of play that showcase how Paranoia is intended to be run and played. Combined with advice on writing adventures—though the designers admit to liking pre-written packaged adventures for various reasons, and beginning, running, and ending adventures, the advice throughout Paranoia is excellent.

The Game Master is further supported with the ‘Adventure Handbook’. It begins a little oddly with the first ten pages devoted to detailing bots (or robots) and vehicles, before presenting a full, pre-packaged, adventure. ‘Destination: CBI Sector’ is designed as a starting adventure and sample of what a Paranoia adventure is intended to look like. This is for both the Game Master new to Paranoia and her players who are new to Paranoia, and the scenario includes a set of six pre-generated Troubleshooters, each of which comes complete with a ‘Mission Report Form’ to fill in and return to the Computer at the end of the mission. The mission involves the recovery of a robot from a previously abandoned industrial sector and will be complicated by whatever the Troubleshooters find there, their duplicitous group leader, and of course, each other. It is a fun, silly, and infuriatingly absurd affair that captures the tone of Paranoia to a tee.

Physically, Paranoia: A Role-Playing Game of a Darkly Humorous Future is Alpha Complex is well presented and wonderfully embraces its black humour. There are constant messages and interactions with the Computer, there are very examples of play, and Jim Holloway’s artwork perfectly captures the absurdities of life in Alpha Complex and the irreconcilable situations that the Troubleshooters will face. Best of all are the covers to the roleplaying game’s three books in the box. Each cover depicts a scene in which those present are being watched by someone else on another cover so that there is a sense of constant sense of surveillance and mistrust even on who the roleplaying game looks. If perhaps there is an oddity in the look of the roleplaying game, it is that Paranoia looks like and it laid out like the rules for wargame rather than a roleplaying game, irony being that this was everything that it was against!

—oOo—
In Space Gamer Number 72 (January/February 1985), Paranoia was given a ‘Featured Review by the Staff of Space Gamer’, that included commentary and annotation in sidebars that ran down the review which was placed in the centre of the page. There was comparison with TOON throughout—also reviewed in the issue—which they begin by pointing out that, “West End Games’ Paranoia is one of a new breed of RPGs. They stress atmosphere and evocation of a certain mood instead of flexible mechanics or long-term playability. These games are, if  you will, the “short story” forms of the field, while the ongoing campaigns of full-scale open-ended games are “novel-length” adventures. You don’t play Paranoia or TOON (for instance) as long-term undertakings; they don’t offer enough variety. But as a change of pace, these games can produce an Intense roleplaying experience.” In general, they were critical of the core mechanics, but concluded by saying, “So there are frustrations in Paranoia — but there is enormous exhilaration too, an adrenalin high that comes from living on full alert every minute. The game system is not for the number­crunchers who want exact percentage chances for everything, novice GMs who have trouble keeping a session rolling along, or players who want relaxation and easygoing fantasy. And if you’re likely to take it personally when your best friend’s character plugs your character from behind, stay away from this game. But if you like high-tension suspense along with a slightly bent sense of humor, Paranoia is a unique and highly desirable experience.”
Marcus L. Rowland reviewed Paranoia in ‘Open Box’ in White Dwarf Issue 65 (May, 1985). He wrote, “I like Paranoia, but I’m not sure that I’d want to run it as a prolonged campaign. It’s the sort of concept which works well as light relief from a ‘serious’ RPG campaign, and will definitely appeal to ‘hack and slay’ merchants. Dedicated rule lawyers and wargamers will hate it. Overall, a lot of fun for a minimum of three or four players.” before giving an overall score of seven out of ten. 
Larry DiTillio reviewed Paranoia in Game Reviews in Different Worlds Issue 39 (May/June 1985). Giving it four out of four stars, he ended a lengthy and detailed review with, “My guess is that Paranoia will have its greatest appeal  among older, more sophisticated gamers seeking a change of pace. Power gamers will definitely hate  it, younger players will probably find it too offbeat. Some of its quips and comments and a lot of  the material on secret soceities [sic] may very well offend a few sensibilities, but this is par for the course in a game that is primarily satirical. And please, take that last comment with a good grain of salt. Paranoia is satirical, but it is no joke. It is a solid, well-designed game, admittedly off-the-wall, but not to be dismissed as an attempt to grab your bucks with a few cheap yuks. Its yuks are good and so is the rest of it. It belongs in every dedicated gamer’s library if only for its insights into the role-playing experience. Well done!”
It was not until Dragon Issue #132 (April 1988) that Jim Bambra reviewed Paranoia in ‘Role-playing Reviews’, subtitled ‘Playing for laughs’ (other roleplaying games reviewed included Ghostbusters and Teenagers From Outer Space), by which time, it was the second edition that being reviewed. He said, “The first edition of Paranoia promised hilarious fun and a combat system that didn’t get bogged down in tedious mechanics. It soon found a following among gamers looking for something different in their role-playing adventures. Still, a close inspection of the combat system revealed that it was slow moving and cumbersome. The mechanics were hard to grasp in places, making it difficult to get into the freewheeling fun. Now, all that’s changed. The Paranoia game has been treated to a revamp, and this time the rules are slick. All that tricky stuff which made the combat system such a pain to run has been shelved off into optional rules. If you want the extra complications, you’re welcome to them, or you can do what most people did anyway and simply ignore them.”
He concluded by asking and answering, “Is the PARANOIA game flawless? Well, not quite. It doesn’t lend itself easily to long-term campaign play. This game is best treated as a succession of short adventure sessions in which players get to enjoy themselves doing all those despicable things that would spoil a more “serious” game. Some players may not like the idea of between-character treachery, but this is such an integral part of the PARANOIA game’s atmosphere that it’s worth abandoning a few scruples in exchange for an evening’s fun. As a tongue-in-cheek science-fiction game, this one is hard to beat. Give it a go; you won’t be disappointed. And remember: The Computer is your friend.” 
Paranoia, Second Edition was also reviewed by John Woods in the ‘Fantasy Games’ section of The Games Machine 003 (February 1988) who wrote, “Paranoia is a lighthearted RPG, ideal for a group fed up with over complex rules and players who take their characters too seriously … and for GMs who want to get their own back! The new edition is far more suitable for those with little or no RPG experience, and is an excellent value for a complete system (just add a 20-sided die). First edition players should consider moving up too – the rule changes aren’t drastic, but improved book organisation makes the GM’s life easier.” Then he signed off with, “‘Remember: Stay Alert! Trust no one! Keep your laser handy!’”
Paranoia was covered not once, but twice in the pages of Arcane magazine. First in Arcane Issue 10 (September 1996) in a Retro Review by editor, Paul Pettengale. He said, “When it first hit the streets, back in May 1985, Paranoia received mixed reviews. It was criticised for being too loose a system, of being too single scenario (rather than campaign) based, and (if you can believe this) of being too much fun. Yes, that sounds mad, but at the time everyone was wrapped up in a realism trip. We were all hooked on character development – a game which, in its five rules for referees, categorically stated, “Kill the bastards” in reference to the player characters was seen as being too anarchic for its own good.”, to which he responded with, “Which was, quite frankly, complete bollocks. Never in gaming history has there been a game which was such a scream to play.” Then he followed this up with, “Despite the fact that a typical Paranoia session resembled a pitch invasion at a Leeds match, only on a somewhat smaller scale, the players achieved a greater level of roleplaying than in the D&D campaign | was running at the time. The reason? The madcap atmosphere, the plots which hardly stretched the brain, and the fact that most of the conversation went on between the players rather than between PCs and NPCs, meant that the players forgot they were playing a game, and got into the somewhat surreal spirit of things. Simplicity, it would seem, when twinned with chaos, makes for a good time in roleplaying games.”
It was also included in ‘The Top 50 Roleplaying Games’ list which appeared in Arcane Issue 14 (Christmas 1996), being placed at position number seven. In answering the question, “What’s it like?”, it said, “For players of games where character development and campaign continuity are a priority, Paranoia is an absolute no-no. If a character (of which there are six versions – each person in Alpha Complex has six clones) lives through an entire scenario then they’re doing well. Hell, they’re doing better than well, they’re probably Jesus Christ reborn (er, no offence intended, all ye Christian types). Suffice to say that Paranoia is, and always will be, a complete laugh – it should be played for nothing more than fun.”
—oOo—

In 1984, Paranoia: A Role-Playing Game of a Darkly Humorous Future was a shockingly radical design that stuck two fingers up and sneered at every roleplaying game that had become before it. It was blatantly uncooperative and adversarial in its play, embracing death in the fragility of its Troubleshooters and almost a nihilism in their uselessness, and possessing a lack of hope given that despite the roleplaying game presenting a means of progression, the actual play was actively obstructive to such progression. This meant the roleplaying game was suited to one-shots and short play rather than campaigns. Lastly, it was the most American and the most anti-American of roleplaying games, especially considering that it was released at the height of the Cold War and the Presidency of Ronald Reagan. It was the most American of roleplaying games because it was rabidly anti-Communist and it fully embraced McCarthyism and pushed the fears that McCarthyism espoused to their fullest extremes—and beyond. It was the most anti-American of roleplaying games because it made every Troubleshooter, every Player Character, what McCarthyism feared—a traitor, effectively a Commie and the enemy within. Of course, that included the Computer and thus Game Master because everyone in Paranoia is the true enemy within. And then the designers of Paranoia effectively turned it into a horrifyingly funny cartoon. It would go on to win the 1984 H.G. Wells Award for Best Roleplaying Rules.

Paranoia: A Role-Playing Game of a Darkly Humorous Future is a brilliant piece of design, a savage satire on roleplaying, politics, and social attitudes at the height of Cold War that set player against player, Game Master against the players, and forced everyone at the table to play differently. All of which it barely hides behind the blackest of humour and the bleakest of futures, whilst presenting a genuinely different and challenging roleplaying experience.

Sunday, 25 December 2022

[Fanzine Focus XXX] Lichcraft

On the tail of the Old School Renaissance has come another movement—the rise of the fanzine. Although the fanzine—a nonprofessional and nonofficial publication produced by fans of a particular cultural phenomenon, got its start in Science Fiction fandom, in the gaming hobby it first started with 
Chess and Diplomacy fanzines before finding fertile ground in the roleplaying hobby in the 1970s. Here these amateurish publications allowed the hobby a public space for two things. First, they were somewhere that the hobby could voice opinions and ideas that lay outside those of a game’s publisher. Second, in the Golden Age of roleplaying when the Dungeon Masters were expected to create their own settings and adventures, they also provided a rough and ready source of support for the game of your choice. Many also served as vehicles for the fanzine editor’s house campaign and thus they showed another DM and group played said game. This would often change over time if a fanzine accepted submissions. Initially, fanzines were primarily dedicated to the big three RPGs of the 1970s—Dungeons & Dragons, RuneQuest, and Traveller—but fanzines have appeared dedicated to other RPGs since, some of which helped keep a game popular in the face of no official support.

Since 2008 with the publication of Fight On #1, the Old School Renaissance has had its own fanzines. The advantage of the Old School Renaissance is that the various Retroclones draw from the same source and thus one Dungeons & Dragons-style RPG is compatible with another. This means that the contents of one fanzine will be compatible with the Retroclone that you already run and play even if not specifically written for it. Labyrinth Lord and Lamentations of the Flame Princess Weird Fantasy Roleplay have proved to be popular choices to base fanzines around, as has Swords & Wizardry. Not every fanzine though, is dedicated to particular roleplaying games.

Lichcraft: An RPG About Trans Necromancers is an overtly political fanzine about a controversial or difficult or political subject (or all three)—depending upon your point of view. Published by Laurie O’Connel Games following a successful Kickstarter campaign as part of ZineQuest #3, it is a dystopian satire upon (fifty) years of Conservative Party rule and access to life changing healthcare in the United Kingdom. It is a commentary upon the Conservative Party and its attitude to both the National Health Service and anyone who does not fit its white middle class ideals. It is also a game for two players which can be run as a multiplayer game and is intended to be quite light-hearted despite the seriousness of its underlying theme. The year is 2069 and the Conservatives have been in power for fifty years, and partially realised its dream of dismantling the NHS with huge cuts and sell-offs to its wealthy backers and as a result, the waiting list to access healthcare for the transgendered community is currently three centuries. So what is a trans person supposed to do? Scream and protest knowing they will be dead before receiving the healthcare they actually need or…? In the case of Lichcraft, it is taking up the study of necromancy in order to become a lich, achieve immortality, and so outlive—or rather, undead the waiting list.

Character creation in Lichcraft is simple. All it requires is that the character is transgendered and on the waiting list. After that, the player is free to decide, or they can roll on the small set of tables to determine their gender, politics, day job, and source of magic. They also assign the numbers one, two, or three to three stats—Strength, Sense, and Spells. Lastly, the character has a Health of five, although this can be lower if there are more players.

My name is Bella
I am 29 years old
I have known that I was trans since I was six
I am Non-Binary
I am a Communist
My hobby is Reading
My day job is Accountant
The source of my magic is Force of Will

Strength 1 Sense 2 Spells 3

Lichcraft is designed to be flexible in that it can be played with one player and one Game Master, one Game Master and several players, or two players without a Game Master. In fact, Lichcraft could just as easily be played by one person and written up as a journaling game. Either way, the aim is for the player to assemble the elements that they need for the ritual. These include a magic spell, some rare and valuable components, and a magically powerful place. These are determined randomly by the Game Master. For example, “The spell is scrawled on the back of envelope, hidden in a cluttered café, and guarded by vampires”,  “The components are in moss gathered from standing stones, hidden in the Houses of Parliament, and guarded by zombie Liz Truss”, and “The location for the ritual is the top of a corporate skyscraper, the catch is the strange weather phenomenon, and the locals are dangerous because they are giants”. Each of these three elements represents a challenge that the would be lich has to overcome to succeed and is done in a single scene each, so that a play through of Lichcraft should be three scenes only.

Within each scene it is the Game Master’s tasks to present obstacles derived from the prompts and objectives already created. If the Player Character needs to overcome an obstacle, then their player rolls a number of dice equal to the appropriate stat. More can be added if the Player Character’s hobby, politics, or other background elements are relevant. If the highest result on any die is a six, the Player Character succeeds and their player narrates the outcome. If three, four, or five, the Player Character succeeds, but may lose a point of Health or the stat being rolled. Lastly, on a one or two, the Player Character fails and something goes wrong. They will also learn a harsh lesson which they can learn from and bring into play later on to gain another die.

There is combat system as such, but the Player Character can lose points of both stats and Health. When all Health is lost, the Player Character is dead. Losing points in a stat represents loss of confidence and a wearing down of the will to succeed, making the challenge of the game more difficult to overcome. Alternatively, a player can decide that their character will make a sacrifice to continue on, whether that is a relationship, career, as sense of independence, and so on, in order to restore two points of Health or a stat. Once the Player Character has gathered everything necessary to perform the ritual, the player has a choice of a final encounter as one last challenge or skipping straight to the ritual. In order to complete the ritual, the rules pose some questions for the player and their character which push them to reflect upon what they have done in order to complete the ritual and how they feel now. Most are chosen by the player, but the Game Master also selects one too.

Lichcraft expands upon the core of the game—which is supported with a nicely done example of play—with multiplayer rules, with alternative settings for the Victorian era, the far future, and Ancient Rome, as well as one parodying a very far future British Science Fiction roleplaying and wargaming setting.

Physically, Lichcraft is a nicely presented. The best artwork is actually inside the front and back covers, and the writing is engaging.

Lichcraft is not about the processes and steps needed to gain gender recognition and the healthcare necessary to support that or the trans experience as it is lived of dealing with the NHS as such, whether that is in the early twenty-first century of today, or the future of the fanzine. Rather it is about overcoming those hurdles and the wait involved—especially the wait involved—in what is as ridiculous a method possible. In doing so, it is making its point in as equally a ridiculous manner possible, but letting the player—who need not be transgendered, because after all, this is a roleplaying game—roleplay that experience out and what it costs in a way that they can understand and appreciate. Ultimately, Lichcraft: An RPG About Trans Necromancers gets its message of frustration and the enormous obstacles which have to be overcome across in one single, entertaining session.