Every Week It's Wibbley-Wobbley Timey-Wimey Pookie-Reviewery...

Friday, 9 August 2019

Ice Cool School 2

Launched at the UK Games Expo 2016, Ice Cool was not just a big hit, it would go on to win the 2016 UK Games Expo Best Children’s Game Winner and the Kinderspiel des Jahres—the children’s game of the year award, similar to the Spiel des Jahres—in 2017. It was the biggest, coolest penguin flipping, fish grabbing, trick shot-taking game on ice ever, and that in a field of flicking games like Rampage or Terror in Meeple City and Flick ‘em Up! Now all that changes, with publisher Brain Games returning to UK Games Expo in 2019 to release Ice Cool 2. With Ice Cool 2, the flicking game goes back to school again, all the way down to the South Pole, and lets the players—or penguins—run round and jump about it as they race to grab fish before the hall monitor can grab them and steal their ID Cards! Played over multiple lunchtimes, the penguin player who gets the most fish and the most Hall Passes is the winner.

Ice Cool 2 is both a standalone game and an expansion to the original Ice Cool. As a standalone game, it is designed for between two and four players, aged six plus, plays very much like Ice Cool, and shares many similarities. The first of these is the ‘Box-In-A-Box’ set-up. Open up the box and nested inside are several smaller box lids. These together with the box base that Ice Cool comes are laid out and clipped together—using the tan fish (plastic in Ice Cool 2 rather than wooden as in Ice Cool)—to form the school and its rooms. Between each of the rooms there are doors and over some of these doors are clipped the fish that the penguin pupils are after.

The second is the penguins themselves. The stars of Ice Cool and thus Ice Cool 2, they are made of plastic, each with a round bottom with a ball bearing weight inside it. A bit like a Weeble. What this means is that when flicked, a penguin will roll. Of course a penguin can roll straight, but flick it from behind on the right hand side and a penguin will curve to the right and flick it from behind on the left hand side and a penguin will curve to the left. Which means that it can go round corners! Yet if you flick a penguin in the head, you can get him to jump, even jump over the walls of the school!

Ice Cool is played in rounds, one round per penguin. In each round one penguin is the Hall Monitor. His job is to catch the other penguins who are trying to get through the doors with the fish and so claim the fish. When a penguin goes through a door with a fish of his colour, he grabs that fish and a Victory Point card. If the Hall Monitor touches another penguin, then he confiscates that penguin’s I.D. Card. Everyone continues flicking their penguins around the school until either one penguin has grabbed all of his fish from over the appropriate doors or the Hall Monitor has confiscated all of the other penguins’ I.D. Cards. At the end of the round, the Hall Monitor receives a Victory Card for each I.D. Card he confiscated. Then the I.D. Cards are handed back and another round begins with play continuing until everyone has been the Hall Monitor and the game ends. The penguin with the most Victory Points wins the game.

The Victory Point cards are worth one, two, or three points. A penguin—whether a penguin or the Hall Monitor—can use pairs of Victory Cards of the same value to activate special abilities. Pairs with a value of one and marked with an image of skates have two uses. The first is to allow a penguin to have another go at the end of his turn, and as long as he has pairs of cards marked with a one and skates, he can keep having another go at the end of his turn. The second is for the penguin—but not the Hall Monitor—can attempt a task. There are three types of task—jump over a wall into another room, pass through two doors in a single flick, or bounce off one wall and pass through one or more doors. Successfully completely a task and a penguin can draw another Victory card. A penguin can use  pairs of cards marked with a one and skates to do either, but not both of these actions. Pairs of Victory cards marked with a two can also be used to move a fish of any colour from atop one door to atop another. The only limit is that it cannot be moved to a door adjacent to a room in which there is a penguin of a matching colour.

The use of the Victory cards not only score a penguin points for the end of the game, but as pairs, they add a tactical element to play. Not just taking another turn, but also taking trick shots to score more Victory cards and to move his rival’s fish, forcing his rival to change plans. Now for younger players, these tactical elements in Ice Cool and Ice Cool 2, may well be too complex or too adversarial, but that is very much down to the judgement of the adults playing with the younger players. This reflects nicely how Ice Cool and Ice Cool 2 can be adjusted to suit both older and younger players, because strip away those tactical aspects and what you have is a flicking game that anyone can play because it relies upon personal skill.

Just as with Ice Cool, Ice Cool 2 is an attractive game with physical presence. It looks great on the table and it really is simple to play. The rules themselves are easy to grasp, but they are not written for the young audience that the game is aimed at. So an adult will need to read through them and teach them to younger players, but they are simple enough to both teach and play. Having done, what players young and old will find is that Ice Cool is fun. The design of the penguins means that skill and trick shots can be taken to get the rolling fish fiends to curve and jump to grab the fish and avoid the Hall Monitor. This physical element means that young and old can play on a level ice field and younger players have a good chance of beating adults. Both of course can get better and better with practice.

As a standalone game, adults will enjoy Ice Cool 2 as much as children, despite it being a children’s game. It provides the same fun as Ice Cool, whilst adding the tactical element, and if you were choosing between purchasing Ice Cool and Ice Cool 2, then Ice Cool 2 would be the better choice. That though, is as a standalone, for Ice Cool 2 shares the same issue as Ice Cool and that there is just the one layout that can be created using its ‘Box-In-A-Box’ set-up. It would have been fun if the game allowed for a variety of school layouts to be created. As standalone games, neither Ice Cool or Ice Cool 2 allow for that option. Ice Cool 2, as an expansion to Ice Cool 2 though…

Included in Ice Cool 2 is a second rulebook, ‘Ice Cool + Ice Cool 2’. When played on their own, both games are designed for between two and four players, but combined, they allow up to eight penguins to flick riot around the school to get fish. This is made possible because the penguins in Ice Cool 2 are of a different colour to those in Ice Cool. They allow the boxes of ‘Box-In-A-Box’ set-up of Ice Cool to be combined with the boxes of ‘Box-In-A-Box’ set-up of Ice Cool 2 to allow different layouts and even sliding boxes which move every turn! They add a new game type, ‘Race Game Mode’, which is really a team mode, with penguins dividing into teams of two to race round the school and collect all of their fish. Any of the layouts suggested in the ‘Ice Cool + Ice Cool 2’ rulebook can be used in ‘Race Game Mode’. (An alternative might be for each player controlling two penguins as a team so that even with just three or four players, they get to play with everything from both Ice Cool and Ice Cool 2.)

Ice Cool is heaps of fun, a game that can be enjoyed by young and old, making it a terrific family game. Ice Cool 2 is heaps of fun, a game that can be enjoyed by young and old, making it a terrific family game. Ice Cool and Ice Cool 2 is together better, providing a bigger game for more penguins and more fun.

Monday, 5 August 2019

Miskatonic Monday #23: Visceral and Emotional Damage

Between October 2003 and October 2013, Chaosium, Inc. published a series of books for Call of Cthulhu under the Miskatonic University Library Association brand. Whether a sourcebook, scenario, anthology, or campaign, each was a showcase for their authors—amateur rather than professional, but fans of Call of Cthulhu nonetheless—to put forward their ideas and share with others. The programme was notable for having launched the writing careers of several authors, but for every Cthulhu Invictus, The Pastores, Primal State, Ripples from Carcosa, and Halloween Horror, there was a Five Go Mad in Egypt, Return of the Ripper, Rise of the Dead, Rise of the Dead II: The Raid, and more...

The Miskatonic University Library Association brand is no more, alas, but what we have in its stead is the Miskatonic Repository, based on the same format as the DM’s Guild for Dungeons & Dragons. It is thus, “...a new way for creators to publish and distribute their own original Call of Cthulhu content including scenarios, settings, spells and more…” To support the endeavours of their creators, Chaosium has provided templates and art packs, both free to use, so that the resulting releases can look and feel as professional as possible. To support the efforts of these contributors, Miskatonic Monday is an occasional series of reviews which will in turn examine an item drawn from the depths of the Miskatonic Depository.

—oOo—

Name: Visceral and Emotional Damage

Publisher: Chaosium, Inc.
Author: Jon Hook

Setting: Any
Product: Reference
What You Get: 1.02 MB, 10-page colour PDF
Elevator Pitch: No more flesh wounds!

Plot Hook: Damage should not just be numbers, but hit locations and injuries.
Plot Development: Lost toes, shattered kneecaps, lost fingers, perforated intestines, pierced lungs, jugular slashed, Sanity loss.
Plot Support: Hit location table, injury location tables, gore descriptors.
Production Values: Decent.

Pros
# Inspired by The Good Friends of Jackson Elias, Episode #143
# Plenty of gore
# Wounds and Sanity losses

Cons
# When is too much detail, too much detail?
# Unsuitable for Pulp Cthulhu: Two-fisted Action and Adventure Against the Mythos

Conclusion
# Works in any period.
# Ow! Ow! That hurts.

Sunday, 4 August 2019

Goodman Games Gen Con Annual II

Since 2013, Goodman Games, the publisher of  Dungeon Crawl Classics Role Playing Game and Mutant Crawl Classics Roleplaying Game – Triumph & Technology Won by Mutants & Magic has released a book especially for Gen Con, the largest tabletop hobby gaming event in the world. That book is the Goodman Games Gen Con Program Book, a look back at the previous year, a preview of the year to come, staff biographies, and a whole lot more, including adventures and lots tidbits and silliness. The first was the Goodman Games Gen Con 2013 Program Book, but not being able to pick up a copy at UK Games Expo this year, the first one to be reviewed is Goodman Games Gen Con 2014 Program Book. (If Reviews from R’lyeh obtains a copy of Goodman Games Gen Con 2013 Program Book then it too will surely be subject to a review…)

The Goodman Games Gen Con 2014 Program Book comes with three scenarios, the first of which is ‘Transatlantic Terror’, a scenario for Call of Cthulhu as part of Goodman Games’ Age of Cthulhu line. Probably one of the last few scenarios to be written and published for Call of Cthulhu, Sixth Edition, Jon Hook’s ‘Transatlantic Terror’ takes place aboard the R.M.S. Adriatic with the investigators taking a trip across the Atlantic in the grand tradition of ‘The Mauretania’ from The Asylum & Other Tales. That said, professionally, I am unable to review it as I edited it (in fact, I had no idea it was even in the Goodman Games Gen Con 2014 Program Book).

Jobe Bittman’s ‘The Emerald Enchanter Strikes Back’ is a sequel to DCC #69: The Emerald Enchanter and designed for eight to ten characters of Second Level. In that scenario, the adventurers penetrated the lair of an emerald-skinned sorcerer who had been abducting and experimenting upon nearby villagers, and of course, put an end to his nefarious plans. Initially spurred on by a desperate villager, the adventurers learn that the emerald sorcerer’s reign of terror may not be over and so must track him down and put an end to him. Again. This is a wilderness adventure, a mini-sandbox in which they will have to follow the clues to locate the sorcerer’s now mobile headquarters—and then fight their way into as it battles them! This is a fun short adventure, a decent sequel, even if a slightly bonkers change of tone.

‘Coming of Age: An Introductory Adventure for Metamorphosis Alpha’ is an adventure for Metamorphosis Alpha: Fantastic Role-Playing Game of Science Fiction Adventures on a Lost Starship written by its designer, James M. Ward. This is a rite of passage adventure intended for players with little experience of the setting, a deadly maze which the characters will need to find their way through and survive. It is a nasty affair, leavening its often deadly combat with a good mix of roleplaying encounters, many of them randomly determined from a given list. It works also as the first scenario in a campaign, imparting to the players and their characters the deadliness of life aboard the Starship Warden.

The ‘DCC Bonus Encounters’ are not full scenarios, but single encounters which came on postcards sent out to customers who pre-ordered particular scenarios and which are intended to be run before or part of a particular scenario. These include DCC 80: Intrigue at the Court of Chaos, DCC 81: The One Who Watches From Below, and DCC 82: Bride of the Black. There are elements here that the Referee could extract and add them to her game, but really they do fit their original scenarios. These are a nice bonus without invalidating the collectible aspect—and Goodman Games supports its community with a lot of things like this—of the original postcards, whilst also making them available in print. 

The Dungeon Crawl Classics Role Playing Game is well known for its artwork and its cover gets its own spotlight in ‘The DCC Cover Design Process’, which showcases how Doug Kovacs works to bring that cover to fruition. The same is done for his ‘DCC Core Book, Gold Foil Cover’, and then again with ‘Covers for “People of the Pit” and “Sailors of the Starless Sea’ and ‘Cover for “The One Who Watches from Below”’. If there is a downside to these sections, it is that they should in colour, because the covers to these books, The One Who Watches from Below, are gorgeous and Doug Kovacs’ art deserves the spotlight.

‘The ABECEDARIAN Adventurer’ adds to another supplement and then previews another. All by Michael Curtis, the first is ‘O is also for Omen’, an addition to The Dungeon Alphabet: An A-Z Reference for Classic Dungeon Design that will be of use to the Referee which wants to add divinationary elements to her campaign. The previews are ‘A is for Android’, ‘B is for Breath Weapon’, ‘C is for Crossbreed’, and ‘X is for Xenotransplantation’ , all for The Monster Alphabet: An A-to-Z Reference for Classic Monster design. They are accompanied by some great artwork and all work as solid pointers and ideas generators for the Referee.

C.L. Werner pens the single piece of fiction in Goodman Games Gen Con 2014 Program Book. ‘Too Tough to Die’ is a short story describing a dungeon run in the world of Xcrawl, Brendan LaSalle’s updating of classic dungeon crawls into a multimedia sporting event. It is a short nasty story about a short nasty dungeon run by a nasty professional Dungeon Master and nicely showcases the difference between a standard Dungeons & Dragons-style game and an Xcrawl game where there is a Dungeon Master who is actually opposed to the professional dungeon crawlers.

The look back at the year just gone begins with ‘Tales from the Road Crew’—the report from the ‘DCC RPG Worlds Tour’, Goodman Games’ demonstration team—a couple of members offering notable events in games they have run the previous year. It is accompanied by a gallery of photographs of some of those games. Other look backs include a reprint of the ‘2014 Mailing Labels’ used on Goodman Games’ packages, again nice to see them all in place and a showcase for the little touches that the publisher uses to strengthen its identity.

And then of course, there is the silliness. For example, there is ‘Dear Archmage Abby’, an agony column aimed at players and Referees of Dungeons & Dragons and Dungeon Crawl Classics Role Playing Game who have questions and problems, whether that is about a particular rule, unrequited love between Dwarf and Elf, or an Anti-Paladin’s poor career choices. It is all very tongue in cheek, though there is a useful answer or two in amongst the silliness, which continues with ‘The Curse of Many Faces’, photos of many of the Goodman Games Road Crew with their faces in a cardboard cutout of Hugh, the swankily be-trousered mascot for Goodman Games.  Hugh himself is seen in action in some photos of ‘The Battle of Gary Con’. The Road Crew come under the spotlight with ‘D40 Questions: The Goodman Gang’ with randomly determined questions from the given table. Informative in an entirely random way.

Rounding out the Goodman Games Gen Con 2014 Program Book is ‘Coming Soon for DCC RPG’ a preview of forthcoming titles. These have all come to print, so the previews are now moot, but what is interesting is the designer notes which accompanies each preview. These are nice tough and make the previews a bit more than just advertising. Lastly, there is Joseph Goodman’s ‘The Vandroid’, the stats and write-up for a classic 1970s Ford custom van as killer android, all inspired by the Dark Horse Comic of the same name. This a weird addition, useful for any time a Dungeon Crawl Classics Roleplaying Game campaign jumps to an alien world.

Physically,  the Goodman Games Gen Con 2014 Program Book is well presented. The writing is engaging and the book is profusely illustrated by the publisher’s stable of artists.

Essentially, the Goodman Games Gen Con 2014 Program Book is an annual. A book of bits and bobs, the silly and the seriously useful, an eclectic mix of the useful and the ephemeral, all illustrated with some great art. Fans of Dungeon Crawl Classics Role Playing Game will definitely enjoy this periodical—though fans of other Goodman Games games will like it too—getting the most out of the support for the roleplaying game as well as look behind the publisher’s Referee’s Screen.

Saturday, 3 August 2019

Sixth Beginning for the Sixth World

The year 2019 marks the thirtieth anniversary of Shadowrun. To mark that date, its publisher, Catalyst Game Labs is releasing an all new edition of the roleplaying game in which man meets machine and magic, corporations are states unto themselves, dragons are CEOs and media personalities. The year is 2080 and the setting is the Sixth World, a future in which shadowrunners run the shadows to undertake missions against corporations, gangs, organised crime, and more, often simply to make a living, but at other times to make a difference. The first release for Sixth Edition is the Sixth World Beginner Box, a quick-start for the new edition designed to introduce both the setting and the rules as well as provide a starting scenario.

Open up the deep box and you will find contents aplenty. This starts with a quick one-sheet guide to what is in the box, preparing the reader for what lies underneath. Underneath is ‘An Instant Guide to the Sixth World’, which explains the setting and history of the Sixth World into just three pages, whilst devoting a fourth to summarising ‘The Big Ten’, the current most powerful, influential, and rich corporations in 2080. It is a quick read, but deftly distills over thirty years of multiple editions of the roleplaying game and accompanying supplements into something which can be read in a few minutes.

Below this are not four character sheets, but four character dossiers. They include a Troll Street Samurai, an Ork Combat Mage, an Elf Covert Ops Specialist/Face, and a Dwarf Decker. Each is eight pages in length and includes a character sheet with a breakdown and explanation of its various parts; background, preferred tactics, and roleplaying tips; and a write-up of a complete Run or mission. It is a simple Run, basically a case of getting into a lightly guarded facility, stealing some data, and getting out again. How it is presented is actually old fashioned, so looks a bit clever by today’s standards. It is divided into two columns. In the left hand column, the narrative of the Run is given, whilst in the right hand column, is an explanation of what skills might used, what dice might be rolled, and what the outcome might be if the Run had been run as a roleplaying session. The Sixth World Beginner Box does this not once, but four times, once for each of the Character Dossiers and thus from a different point of view each time. Read each of these recaps for the Run and you get a nice idea of not just how each character approaches the Run, not just in terms of roleplaying, but also in terms of their role on the team and they do. The only issue with the set of Character Dossiers is that there is not a Human among them and so do not reflect the mix of Metahumanity—Dwarves, Elves, Orks, and Trolls—and Humans in the Sixth World. (That said, a Human Rigger, a Drone or vehicle pilot, is available to download as an expansion to the Sixth World Beginner Box.)

Characters in the Sixth World Beginner Box and thus Shadowrun, Sixth Edition have eight attributes, plus two or three special attributes, depending upon their character type. The primary attributes are Body, Agility, Reaction, Strength, Willpower, Logic, Intuition, and Charisma, and whilst all characters will have the special attributes, Essence and Edge, only spellcasting characters have the Magic attribute. As in previous editions, the value for attributes typically ranges between one and six, but can be higher. Of the special attributes, Essence is a measure of a character’s nervous system and spirit, whilst Edge represents the ability to do amazing things within the bounds of the setting. Characters also have skills, typically rated between one and nine, which have been greatly streamlined and condensed in comparison to previous editions. All of the gun skills are not represented by the Firearms skill for example, but it is still possible to specialise in weapon types. Characters also have Knowledge skills and Qualities, sort of advantages and disadvantages, but whilst the characters have them in the Sixth World Beginner Box, they are not explained and do not play a role in the game. Really they are there for flavour and detail, though experienced players of Shadowrun may want to bring them into play.

The new rules are explained in the twenty-four page ‘Quick Start Rules’ booklet. As with previous editions of Shadowrun, it uses a dice pool mechanic to generate successes and the more successes or Hits a player rolls, the better his character does. To have his character undertake an action, his player rolls a number of six-sided dice, aiming to roll fives or sixes. Each five or six rolled is a Hit and the more rolled above a task’s threshold or more than an opposing character, the better the character does, but if more than half of the dice come as a one, then a ‘Glitch’ has been rolled and something goes wrong for the character. Dice pools are typically formed from a skill plus a linked attributes, such as Firearms and Agility, Sorcery and Magic, and Influence and Charisma, with modifications adding to or detracting from the dice pool. It should be noted that characters can get a lot of dice to roll, often ten or more.

Besides having a lot of dice to roll, what the players and their characters also possess something that gives them the edge, and that is, well, Edge. Every character has an Edge Pool equal to his Edge attribute at the start of every session and his player can spend Edge points from the pool to give the character an advantage in a situation or encounter, for example rerolling a die, giving Edge to an Ally, gaining an automatic Hit, adding more dice to roll, rerolling failed dice, healing damage, or even forcing an opponent to roll a glitch. These all have varying costs and a player can only spend Edge on one of these options on a turn. In the Sixth World Beginner Box, Edge can be gained through having tactical advantage in a situation, up to a maximum of seven. Hopefully more options will be provided in Shadowrun, Sixth Edition to gain Edge through play and roleplaying, what the Sixth World Beginner Box introduces is an Edge economy, with a flow going in and out of each character’s Edge pool.

Combat involves multiple dice rolls, but still feels quite streamlined. Characters get to maneuvre before they act, check to see if they gain any Edge, and expend Edge as necessary, but then their players get to roll dice. So when a shadowrunner fires at a ganger with his Ares Light Fire 75 light pistol, his player rolls dice equal to his shadowrunner’s Agility and Firearms, whilst the Game Master would roll the ganger’s Reaction and Intuition. So for a shadowrunner with Agility 4 and Firearms 3, his player would roll seven dice, whilst the Game Master would roll six dice for the Ganger’s Reaction 3 and Intuition 3. The shadowrunner’s player rolls 1, 3, 4, 5, 5, 6, and 6, whilst the Game Master rolls 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, and 6. This gives two extra Hits to add to the weapon’s Damage Value of 2. That is a total of 4 Hits against which the Game Master will roll four dice the Ganger’s Body of 3 and his ganger leathers which give him +1. The Game Master rolls 1, 3, 4, and 6 for one Hit, which means that the Ganger takes three damage.

The rules for the Matrix and Netrunning use the same mechanics, whether a Decker is scanning for a wireless feed or the presence of corporate decker, taking control of a set of security cameras, hacking open a data file, and so on. Basically, a Decker’s player will either be rolling his character’s Electronics and Logic if action is legal, but Cracking and Logic if not, choosing from a mix of legal (edit file, enter/exit host, jack out, and Matrix perception) and (crack file, data spike, format device, hack, snoop, and spoof command) illegal actions. An interesting limitation upon a Decker’s actions in the Matrix is Convergence, which occurs when a Decker has done too much and attracted the attention of the Grid Overwatch Division, illegal actions in particular attracting their attention. When Convergence occurs, the Decker is dumped from the Matrix, his cyberdeck is bricked and rendered useless, and law enforcement is called to their meatspace location. Overall, it adds an urgency to all decking operations in the Matrix, whilst the mechanics are easy and fast, giving netrunning an immediacy that was not always present in previous editions.

Lastly, there is magic, and that too uses the same mechanics. The traditions are Hermetic and Shamnic magic, all just using the Sorcery, Conjuring, and Enchanting skills. The danger of casting magic is that spellcasters can suffer from Drain, causing fatigue, and a spellcaster can only improve the effectiveness of a spell—Amp up a combat spell for extra damage or Increase Area effects for spells with area effects—by increasing the effects of Drain. Fortunately, a spellcaster can Soak the Drain Value of a Spell, using either Logic and Magic if a Hermetic Mage or Charisma and Magic if a Shaman. Again Shadowrun, Sixth Edition will add more detail, but the mechanics for magic in the Sixth World Beginner Box cover just about everything the Ork Combat Mage will need just as the rules for the Matrix cover everything the Dwarf Decker will need.

The second book in the Sixth World Beginner Box is the ‘Battle Royale Adventure’. The adventure begins in a Stuffer Shack supermarket and if that is enough to cause veteran players of Shadowrun to groan—the first adventure for Shadowrun, ‘First Run’, which appeared in the first edition was essentially a fight in a mini-mart—then there is no need to be on that account, for it is only the start. The shadowrunners are in the Stuffer Shack when something goes down outside and in the warehouse complex opposite, a four-way gang showdown over a limousine and its passengers. It comes with advice for the Game Master, a map or two, and some NPC stats. In general, the players are free to approach the situation however they want—stealth, charm, diplomacy, out and out combat—and there is good advice for all of that for the Game Master  (though it could have been organised to more obvious during play), but it is a terrible scenario.

The problem is that it is a set-up to help both the Game Master and her players work out the rules. Which is fine, because that is what you want in a quick-start or an introduction to a roleplaying game. Yet it is no more than that. There is no plot to speak of that the player characters will get involved in; there is no beginning, middle, or ending, it is just a set-up for the player characters to be pulled into, resolve, and no more. The backstory for that set-up involves Seattle and Washington, DC politics, but there is no way for that to come out in play and there is no sense of Seattle as a place because it takes place in one location. In fact, it is so annoying unsophisticated in its lack of storytelling and development, it does not actually read like a scenario for a roleplaying, but an encounter for a wargame. And that is exactly what it is.

Above all, what ‘Battle Royale Adventure’ does not do is provide a means for the pre-generated player characters to do what they are supposed to—and that is, to go on a ‘Run’. In fact, what the Sixth World Beginner Box does instead is tell the players, in each character dossier, how a run through the shadows might go down without the players having any influence over it. Given how irrelevant the ‘Battle Royale Adventure’ actually is except as a combat encounter, the Game Master could actually tell her players not to read the fiction in their character dossiers and then she could run the run that the characters go on in that run. It would be a better illustration of a Shadowrun adventure than the ‘Battle Royale Adventure’.

In addition, the Sixth World Beginner Box comes with an excellent poster map of Seattle—which would be even better if more of it was involved in the ‘Battle Royale Adventure’, a dozen Shadowrun six-sided dice—not quite enough for some of the pre-generated characters in the box, and a set of fifty-four quick-reference tool cards for items, weapons, spells, and stats for the NPCs in the adventure. Physically, all of this is presented in full colour, on glossy card, with fantastic illustrations. The cards are perhaps a little flimsy and it would have been nice if they had been illustrated too as they would have increased their versatility, but otherwise, the production values on the Sixth World Beginner Box are excellent. 

The Sixth World Beginner Box is an impressive set. It is a great introduction to Shadowrun, Sixth Edition, with some excellent pre-generated characters and well presented rules that are easy to read and understand. Veteran players of Shadowrun will find a lot here that is familiar and mechanics that are easy to run and play, whilst those new will be enticed by the nicely done pre-generated characters and the quality of the components before discovering the ease of the rules. Unfortunately, both will find the single encounter that is ‘Battle Royale Adventure’ a dreadful disappointment. As written, there is nothing wrong with the single encounter that is ‘Battle Royale Adventure’, but as a Shadowrun adventure and as an introduction to playing Shadowrun it is singular in nature and severely lacking in terms of plot and story, and that lack fundamentally betrays the quality and purpose of the Sixth World Beginner Box.

Friday, 2 August 2019

Friday Fiction: H.P. Lovecraft’s Dagon for beginning readers

Much like the earlier H.P. Lovecraft’s The Call of Cthulhu for beginning readers, the cartoon cartoon artwork and simple prose of H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers would suggest that it is a book for children. Unlike the various Call of Cthulhu ABC books to the delightful Where’s My Shoggoth? which have successfully melded the Cosmic Horror of Lovecraft’s fiction with the children’s author of your choice in a format which can be enjoyed by children, H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers uses the form of the children’s book to retell a tale of cosmic horror whose conclusion might be a legitimate response to the cosmic horror at its heart, it is a conclusion that is highly unsuitable for younger readers.

Published by Chaosium, Inc., what H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers does is bring both the prose style and the art style of Theodor Seuss Geisel—or Dr. Seuss—to the works of H.P. Lovecraft, or rather to one of Lovecraft’s earliest stories, ‘Dagon’. This is written as the last testament of an ex-sailor driven to drugs by a strange encounter in the Pacific during his service in the Great War. When his ship is captured by an Imperial German sea-raider, he escapes in a lifeboat, but with little idea of where he is, he drifts aimlessly until he suddenly awakes to find himself on land again, but not land he has ever seen. It is a mire of black mud, lifeless and undulating, reeking from the stench of decaying fish, perhaps thrown up from the sea floor. Searching for a way to the sea, he makes his way to the only landmark of note, a hill, beyond which he finds a chasm. Inside he discovers a monolith crudely carved with creatures of the sea and depiction of fish-like men, but then he is disturbed by a fish thing of great size and hideousness.  Fleeing to the surface and a great storm, the narrator next awakens in a San Francisco hospital, but when tells his tale, no believes him and no expert can corroborate his experiences. As time on the strange island haunts his nightmares, his fears grows that the fish thing and others will come for him and mankind, and as scratches are heard at his door, he is driven to suicide.

As with H.P. Lovecraft’s The Call of Cthulhu for beginning readers, author and artist R.J. Ivankovic presents H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers in the anapestic tetrameter rhyming cadence and art style of Dr. Seus. Yet where the combination of styles leavened Lovecraft’s sometimes heavy style and effectively portrayed the horror of story in H.P. Lovecraft’s The Call of Cthulhu for beginning readers, in H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers is not quite as effective. The text is sparse, but often feels forced, verses interspersed between great swathes of blue and black, that only serve to give the book an incredibly bleak look and feel. That may well fit the source, but it does not make for as riveting a story as in H.P. Lovecraft’s The Call of Cthulhu for beginning readers. Then there is the ending, which renders H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers unsuitable for any but a mature audience, and certainly not for ‘beginning readers’.

Ultimately, the issue with H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers is the source story. It begins well enough, the encounter with the Imperial German Navy commerce raider being given a nicely done piratical touch, but once it descends on the desolate mire of the strange island, there is little that R.J. Ivankovic’s art can do to lift the bleakness of the story and there is little that he can do with the text either, which feels leaden despite being in anapestic tetrameter. It does not help that the sparseness of the text—as much as it enforces the bleakness of both story and art—actually breaks up the story.

Nevertheless, the artwork in H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers is excellent, inspired by and perfectly aping the style of Dr. Seus. Although cartoon-like, this art never shies away from portraying the horror described in the text. Yet the  bleakness of both story and art, the terrible nature of the end, do make that horror explicit and overbearing, and so H.P. Lovecraft's Dagon for Beginning Readers is not suitable for any but mature readers—as Chaosium makes clear—and it is all just a little blue. There is no doubt that the format really works, as seen in H.P. Lovecraft’s The Call of Cthulhu for beginning readers, so hopefully the author will select a better story for the next story in the series.

Friday Fantasy: Grinding us

In 2019, The Grinding Gear is ten years old and Forgive Us – Being A Chronicle of the Events Surrounding the Mysterious Disappearance of the Notorious Criminal Gang Known as the Tenebrous Hand. And Other Stories is five years old. Both are scenarios for use with Lamentations of the Flame Princess Weird Fantasy Roleplaying and other ‘Old School’ fantasy roleplaying games. The first is a short, but stunning deathtrap dungeon in the vein of the infamous S1 Tomb of Horrors for Advanced Dungeons & Dragons, First Edition, but designed for characters of First Level. The second is a piece of naturalistic design, a dungeon that is not a dungeon, a thieves den definitely containing something that neither the thieves nor the player characters want to encounter… To celebrate the dual anniversaries, Andre Novoa—best known as the author of the scenario, The Squid, the Cabal, and the Old Man—has published a scenario inspired by both. 

Grinding Us takes place in the same world as The Grinding Gear and Forgive Us, but geographically, in the same location as The Grinding Gear. In that scenario, an innkeeper took revenge upon adventurers after his daughter fell in love with one, ran off with him, and got killed whilst on an adventure. In revenge, he designed a dungeon to tweak the curiosity of other adventurers and so send them underground and there kill with a series of traps and puzzles. In Grinding Us, the player characters come to that same in, but not to visit (or revisit) The Grinding Gear dungeon. Instead, they are simply passing through when they overhear a group of men talking of a(nother) dungeon a few miles away, full of treasure and just waiting to be delved into and looted. There is even a ‘handy’ map of the dungeon complex for the player characters to find when the trio accidentally drop it and leave it behind when they leave.

The dungeon lies beneath a convent (which appears to have had both monks and nuns) that lies abandoned surrounded by wilderness. There are traps and puzzles right from the start, as well as some hints as to what lies below. Whilst there are two or three monsters to be encountered, in the main, this is not a dungeon with much in the way of combat, focusing instead on exploration, investigation, and examination of their environment in order to work out the puzzles worked throughout its corridors and rooms. The dungeon is not straightforward either, the delvers likely to return to certain points to work what various features—particularly the numerous levers—do when fiddled or interacted with, as they are not immediately obvious (and intentionally so). This less than straightforward design also means that the Referee will need to pay attention to the state of various features of the dungeon and it is probably a good idea for her to prepare a status sheet for the current states of those features and so keep track of them that way…

One of the features that Grinding Us shares with The Grinding Gear is a lack of treasure. This again, is intentional. In The Grinding Gear the promise of treasure drew the player characters deeper into the dungeon in order to make them suffer, as after all, the deeper into the dungeon you get, the more likely there is of there being more treasure—or at least, treasure. In Grinding Us, the same drive works, but here the aim is not to make the player characters suffer, though they will if they fail to get past the dungeon’s traps, solve its puzzles, and so on. Rather, the dungeon is designed as a test, a test of skills for the Thief (or Specialist Class if playing Lamentations of the Flame Princess Weird Fantasy Roleplaying) as a hiring method. The ‘potential’ employers in this case is actually a Thieves Guild, the Tenebrous Hand, which appears in another scenario, and of course, that scenario is Forgive Us. Their presence is prevalent throughout the convent and dungeon, if not in person, then in the hands which decorate the walls and feature in some of the traps and puzzles of the complex. One sign of that failure is for the Thief (or other player character) is to lose one or both hands, and there is plenty of opportunity for that in the dungeon.

There are some decent traps to be found in Grinding Us, but where it is weakest is in its riddles. These are more like trivia questions about the dungeon which the player characters are themselves exploring and of course have forgotten to take notes about. This is definitely a dungeon that the players are going to want to map and the Game Master should probably encourage them to do so. It may well be their source of clues for some of the questions their characters will have to answer.

Physically, Grinding Us is a thirty-five page, 3.05 MB, full-colour PDF. It is very lightly illustrated, the artwork really only serving to break up rather than serve the text, but the maps are decent, whilst the one handout is clear and easy to use. The adventure is very easy to scale, it having no suggested playing Level in terms of the characters, and all the Game Master has to do is adjust the damage inflicted in the various encounters.

Grinding Us is a reasonable enough dungeon. It needs careful staging by the Game Master in order to keep track of its various traps and tricks, and it needs a more meticulous, more careful style of play by the player characters and their adventurers. This is part of the very nature of deathtrap dungeons, but it does not suit every playing group. Grinding Us is a nice nod to both The Grinding Gear and Forgive Us, and probably best used either to tweak your player characters’ curiosity or put the Thief in the players’ party to the test or move them onto more professional adventures.

Thursday, 1 August 2019

The Cyberpunk IV Starter

Cyberpunk returns in 2019. The original roleplaying game which drew from Cyberpunk literary subgenre—of which William Gibson’s Neuromancer was a leading example—was first published by R. Talsorian Games Inc. in 1988 as Cyberpunk (now known as Cyberpunk 2013) before being given as a second edition as Cyberpunk 2.0.2.0. in 1990. Putting aside the less than well-received Cyberpunk V3.0 of 2005, what is in effect the fourth edition of the roleplaying game—Cyberpunk Red—comes out ahead of the highly anticipated computer roleplaying game, Cyberpunk 2077, but is itself given a preview in the form of the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit. This is a quick-start for the roleplaying game, which introduces both the new rules and the updated background, both of which will be familiar to veteran Game Masters and players of previous versions of Cyberpunk, as well as providing a full scenario to play and several hooks for the Game Master to develop. The Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit comes with both a Jumpstart Rulebook and a Jumpstart Worldbook, plus a Rules Reference, four battle maps, a set of character and vehicle standees, and six pre-generated characters. This is all included in both the physical and PDF versions—the version being reviewed here—of the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit and the only major difference between the two is the inclusion of dice in the physical version.

Cyberpunk Red takes place in the Time of the Red. The Golden Age of Cyberpunk, of freewheeling embrace of technology, acceptance of cyberware as a way of life, of easy access to the NET where Netrunning console cowboys and cowgirls jockeyed for prestige as raided corporate networks, of the massive growth of corporations as extraterritorial entities, all radically dividing the future into one of extreme haves and havenots. That ended on August 20th, 2023, when a ‘pocket nuke’ was detonated in the Arasaka headquarters in the west coast metroplex of Night City. It ended the Fourth Corporate War between Arasaka and Militech, devastated Night City, and brought economic and environmental devastation to the world, causing a depression which continues two decades on... It ended corporate domination, reducing corporations to being local and international; turned much of the USA into a new Wild West where safe travel could often be promised by the Nomad tribes. For years after the nuclear detonation, the sky was red and still is at dawn dusk, leading the new age to be known as the Time of the Red.

Night City is a frontier town, an independent city state rebuilding after the effects of the bomb. Services, supplies, and law enforcement are what you pay for. The reduced corporations still supply and provide almost everything, from power to food to medical services to media, often brought in by Nomad tribes that run transport in the new North America, independents do grow real food though, and whilst the corporations have their own security, freelancers and bodyguards are available for hire, though the city maintains a Maximum Force Tactical Division or ‘Psycho Squad’ or ‘MAX–TAC’ which handles cybernetic criminals or anyone suffering from Cyberpsychosis. As inhabitants of Night City, you get your information from city wide freestanding dataterms and news from screamsheets downloaded to a personal agent helps you with your daily life from phone calls to shopping; you wear clothing able to emit sounds and video, even monitor your condition; you do your shopping at self-contained, armed and armoured Vendits; you eat kibble or good prepack food if you can; and you go armed. Either a Polymer One-shot easily bought or printed, or something bigger purchased from a Fixer after it has been scavenged from the Fourth Corporate War or smuggled into the city. The same goes for Cyberware... 

In terms of what you can play, Cyberpunk Red offers nine roles or Edgerunners—Execs, Fixers, Lawmen, Medias, Nomads, Netrunners, Rockerboys, Solos, and Techs. In the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit, just six of these are provided as pre-generated characters. They are a Fixer, a Netrunner, a Nomad, a Rockerboy, a Solo, and a Tech. Fixers are dealmakers smugglers, organisers, and information brokers; Netrunners are the cybernetic master hackers of the post-NET world and brain burning secret stealers; Nomads are transportation experts and the ultimate road warriors; Rockerboys are rock and roll rebels who use performance and rhetoric to fight authority; Solos are assassins bodyguards, killers, and soldiers for hire in a lawless new world; and Techs are renegade mechanics and doctors patching up meat and metal alike. Each pre-generated Edgerunner is given a two-page character sheet. On the front is an illustration and some background, whilst on the reverse are the stats, skills, armour, weapons, cyberware and gear, and life path. Skills, armour, weapons, cyberware, and gear are all fixed, but stats and lifepath are not. So the Rockerboy wears Kevlar armour on her head and body, is armed with a heavy pistol, and has Cyberaudio and a Slice & Dice monowire cyberware installed, but like all of the pre-generated Edgerunners, she has a table of stat arrays to roll on and blank spaces on the lifepath. Before play, a player simply rolls on the table of stat arrays to get his character’s stats and then rolls on the Lifepath table—a feature of Cyberpunk going all the way back to Cyberpunk 2013 and replicated in a stripped back version in the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit—to determine his Background, Motivation, Goals, Friends (other than the player characters), Enemies, Romance, and Personality. This nicely adds a degree of variation between the player characters and gets them rolling dice even before play.

At the heart of Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit are two books, the forty-five page ‘Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Rule Book’ and the fifty-three page ‘Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart World Book’. Intended for both Game and player, ‘Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Rule Book’ quickly delves into what Cyberpunk Red is all about—style over substance, attitude over everything, and living on the edge in fighting a cause those that would oppress you, from rapacious corporations and nihilistic boostergangs to road raiders and organised crime. It covers various aspects of the Cyberpunk setting, such as a cyberfashion, cyberpsychosis, and cyberware, the latter exploring how they work and where they can be obtained. It breaks down a character, explaining what the stats and skills are as well as what the three means of character generation are in Cyberpunk Red. These are Street Rat (templates), Edgerunner (fast and dirty via dice rolls on tables), and The Complete Package (point construction), with the Street Rat method having been used in the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit. Notably missing from the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit are Role Abilities. In Cyberpunk Red, each of the various Roles—or character types—has an ability associated with it, for example, ‘Streetdeal’ for Fixers and ‘Combat Sense’ for Solos, but in the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit, only the Netrunner has her Role Ability, ‘Interface’, which she uses when Netrunning.

Mechanically, the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit and so Cyberpunk Red uses the Interlock system. In general, for his Edgerunner to do anything, a player will roll a ten-sided die and add the Edgerunner’s Stat and Skill (or Role Ability) to the result in order to beat a Difficulty Value. This Difficult Value is fourteen for an Everyday task, eighteen for a Competent task, twenty-two for Heroic, and so on. Critical successes—rolls of ten—enable a player to keep rolling and adding to his total as long as he keeps rolling ten, whereas Critical failures—rolls of one—forces him to roll again and subtract from the total, but just the once. In combat, chases, and so on, the rolls tend to be opposed, both sides rolling and adding their character’s Stat and appropriate Skill.

Where in previous editions of Cyberpunk, combat was handled in the ‘Friday Night Firefight’ rules, but in Cyberpunk Red it is covered in ‘Thursday Night Throwdown’. They present a set of streamlined rules in just a few pages, but designed for ease of play and to avoid getting mired in details. Notably though, they include rules for handling reputational combat, enabling Edgerunners and NPCs to face off against each other without the need to draw weapons (yet). Overall, the rules feel slicker and easier to understand, there being not too much for the Game Master to learn and impart to her players.

There is though a bit more to learn and handle when it comes to Netrunning. Whatever the Cyberpunk-inspired roleplaying game—Cyberpunk 2.0.20. or Shadowrun—handling the virtual space of the Matrix and one player character’s interactions within it, has always been a time consuming process. In Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit and so Cyberpunk Red, netrunning is still relatively complex, but because the NET is no longer accessible, in the Time of the Red, a Netrunner has to accompany his fellow Edgerunners in order to access the target facility’s local VPN on the spot, accessing cyberspace via a cyberdeck and viewing it through Virtuality goggles–headsets which project cyberspace imagery over the ‘meatspace’ view of the world. Like combat in ‘Thursday Night Throwdown’, netrunning has been simplified and streamlined, a Netrunner typically moving from level to level in a VPN via an elevator, scanning and mapping the VPN in an attempt to locate an objective, control nodes for Meatspace devices, and so on, avoiding or fleeing Black ICE (Intrusion Countermeasures Electronics). Since this all takes place in the virtual space, the likelihood is that a Netrunner will have more actions than his compatriots outside in Meatspace, so will be doing more and so taking up more time between himself and the Game Master.

There is a lot to learn here in comparison to the rest of the mechanics and setting presented in the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit, hence the Netrunning rules receiving a whole chapter of their own. The rules do feel slicker and easier than in previous editions of Cyberpunk and it helps that there is an extended sample of play, but this is the one chapter in the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit that requires close study.

The ‘Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart World Book’ covers the history and setting of Cyberpunk Red from 1990 to 2045, focusing primarily on Night City and its environs in the aftermath of the Fourth Corporate War. Much of it comes with commentary from an in-game historian and commentator, whilst for the Game Master is given good advice on running Cyberpunk Red, including reasons why disparate characters would be together and how their Roles would work in a series of different team concepts, types of missions which could be run, and a discussion of the style and tone of a game. Rounding the ‘Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart World Book’ is a single adventure, ‘The Apartment’, and three scenarios. The three scenarios are built around Screamsheets and in turn involve a hijacking, a hostage situation, and a raid. The Game Master will need to do a bit more development and preparation on the three scenarios, but all come with clever twists and interesting set-ups. ‘The Apartment’ is more involving and adheres to the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit’s adage for the Game Master to keep it personal. This has the Edgerunners all living in the same apartment block when a corporation decides to take possession. The Edgerunners get to interact with the other residents before it all goes down, whilst the Game Master is given multiple options as to how the corporation moves in as well actions that the various player character Roles might undertake in defence of their homes. There is room here for her to expand the scenario just a little, perhaps have the corporation make multiple attempts. This is a really nice little adventure, one that gives the player and their Edgerunners a sense of home and place, in readiness for the scenarios to come.

In addition, the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit includes an ‘EZ Reference’ sheet in two formats—a four-page portrait format and a two-page tabloid format; a set of standees to print out and use, which includes the pre-generated Edgerunners, vehicles, and NPCs; and four maps, a street corner, a section of the open road, an office area, and a bar. All are done in full colour with the ‘EZ Reference’ sheet giving the basic mechanics, Ranged to Hit difficulties, weapon damages, action and combat modifiers, cyberware details, Netrunner actions, and NPCs.

Physically, everything in the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit is presented in full colour. The layout is clean and tidy, the illustrations are fully painted pieces and excellent. Barring the need for a little editing in places, the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit is a readable product.

There are two issues with the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit. One is that its background does not do what good Cyberpunk does, and that is that it does not fetishise product names and models. No weapons or cyberware are named, so that all of the gear feels flat and generic, rather than giving flavour as it should. The other is the complexity of the Netrunning rules, which are time consuming in comparison to the rest of the rules in the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit. The first issue can at best be ignored, but the second will require a little more study on the part of both the Game Master and the Netrunner player. Then patience in play by the rest of the players.

Although it does not give every option (some players may be disappointed by only having six Roles available), the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit gives a solid snapshot of the Time of the Red and the Roles of the players can roleplay, all supported by solid mechanics and some decent, though short scenarios. Overall, the Cyberpunk Red Jumpstart Kit is a slick introduction to the updated world of Cyberpunk Red in an attractive and accessible package.