‘The Caprine Cure’ by Colin Richards places the rich and the venal at a special, invitation-only health and wellness event with a reputation for being truly restorative, even transformative, held at the Caprine Springs Resort, an exclusive woodland spa in the Appalachian hills of West Virginia. This is a story of temptation and choice rather than of investigation, as the Player Characters are offered one treatment after another and given a range of ingredients to select from for their final cure at the end of the weekend. Their fate is one of transformation in the service of the ‘cult’ that operates the spa, though whether this is willingly or unwillingly—and in what form—is the ultimate choice for both player and character. Although this reads far more as a novel than a scenario, one that suggests a secret organisation behind the rich, famous, and powerful, it is atmospheric, the pre-generated Player Characters are suitably unpleasant, and whatever the final choice, get their just rewards.
David Waldron’s ‘The Witch’s Bargain’ is the first of two scenarios in The Year of the Goat written for use with Cthulhu: Dark Ages, though neither is actually set in the Dark Ages. It is an action-packed, character-led affair which takes place on Walpurgis Night in the fens of Suffolk during the English Civil War and it begins en media res. The Player Characters have just attempted and failed to rob a Royalist convoy and now their bodies and egos wounded—possibily quite literally in the case their bodies, have fled into the nearby wetlands. They carry with them not only their sense of failure, but guilt for crimes, petty and otherwise, they have each committed. Marked by omens and harassed by a black dog, the Black Shuck of legend, trekking deeper into the fens they encounter their own regrets and a terrible scene of a woman being condemned as a witch. She returns in the final encounter to offer the Player Characters a means to escape their pasts, but whether it offers salvation is another matter. This combines a fantastic otherworldliness with a strong character focus.
Jayson Green’s ‘In Sorte Diaboli’ goes deep into the woods in nineties Finland as an up and coming metal band’s plans to shoot a music video go horribly awry. Their music is subverted by Pan, an avatar of Shub-Niggurath, but it may be their only salvation as they are chased through the forest by the wild ones that worship the avatar. It is effectively a chase scenario as the Player Characters attempt to escape both the clutches of the cult and what they might transform into. It is a solid enough affair that plays to nicely paired themes.
‘The Convent of Sancta Maria Lactans’ by Robin Worthy is the other
Cthulhu: Dark Ages scenario in the anthology. This time the scenario is set in Tudor England with the Investigators as agents of Cardinal Wolsey with Thomas Cromwell as their patron, at a time when King Henry VIII is becoming increasingly dissatisfied with the efforts of his wife, Queen Catherine of Aragon, to give him an heir. Wolsey directs the Investigators to look into the affairs of Convent of Sancta Maria Lactans, whose sisters are rumoured to have fallen into heretical beliefs and malpractice. Worse, it is known that the Queen is one of the Convent’s benefactors and has made a pilgrimage there. If the sisters’ practices are no Christian, what does this say of the Queen? There is a lot going on in the background of the scenario, which can easily be used to set-up a campaign—and to that end the author should definitely write some sequels as this period is not explored widely enough in
Call of Cthulhu. Though short, the scenario offers some investigation before getting to the Convent and ends with a great set piece. Plus, if there are any survivors, the epilogue has a nasty little twist which makes you want that sequel!
Olga Patijn’s ‘The Festival of the All-Mother’ is butt-clenchingly brilliant. It is a very contemporary scenario in which the Player Characters are the parents of teenage girls who have become enamoured of a trio of social media influencers known as the ‘Cult of the All Mother’ which promotes feminine wellness as well as hyper fertility, female rage, and sexual dominance. So concerned, they have agreed to collectively chaperone their daughters to a festival organised by the influencers and hope that they can try to get them out of its clutches. The festival has a very bright and breezy, upbeat tone to it, tempered of course, by the misandry and inversion of male rage at women, which actually makes it feel uncomfortable. This is intentional as the author is upending some of the worst of today’s cultural trends and expecting the players to roleplay parents who are mostly trying and mostly failing to do their best for their daughters. This adds an emotional depth to the scenario which is rarely present in
Call of Cthulhu and makes it a more involving and more demanding scenario. Plus, it gets points for the term, ‘GoatCore aesthetic’.
The Texas Chain Saw Massacre meets Shub-Niggurath in ‘The House of Flesh’ by Antonio Marchena. A group of friends fleeing a hurricane which has struck Houston is forced to take shelter at an isolated farmhouse after the car is driven into a flooded ditch, but things are definitely about to take a turn for the worse because the farmer and her malformed grandson have plans for them. Can the Player Characters avoid ending up in the pot on the stove or sacrificed to the monster in the barn and escape to the safety of the hurricane? This is a short, sharp, and straightforward slasher horror scenario in which the cannibal clan has two mothers.
What if the rain maker came to town and was not a servant of the devil, but a worshipper of the fecundity of Shub-Niggurath? In Maverick Haenze’s ‘To Serve in Heaven’, set on the Desperate Decade of the 1930s, four down-on-their-luck transients, driven out of their homes by the combined effect of the Wall Street Crash and Dust Bowl, find a paradise in Liberty Corners, Texas. It seems too good to be true, and when they discover it is, the Player Characters have to decide whether it is worth making a sacrifice for. The townsfolk have clearly made the choice and are friendly, happy, and helpful people, so surely it would be a sin to reject their hospitality? The grubby and down-at-heel state of the Player Characters thematically contrasts with the paradise that they find and the setting is very appropriate for an appearance by Shub-Niggurath. (Unfortunately, there are no stats for the villain of the piece.)
‘Nos Galan Gaeaf’ by Lydia Malings is the only scenario for
Cthulhu by Gaslight in the anthology and will probably longer the typical four-hour running time of the other entries. It is set in the village of Llanwencoed in the South Wales Valleys in 1899 on Nos Galan Gaeaf, the Welsh equivalent of Halloween or ‘Winter’s Eve’. The Investigators are young women looking forward to the festivities when their friend, Tomas Andrews, the son of the most well-to-do family in the village goes missing and the reverend of the village chapel is attacked, it is clear that something strange is going on. The scenario is richly steeped in Welsh folklore and tradition, subverting it, of course, for the purposes of the scenario, and also subverting the traditional Call of Cthulhu scenario of having outsiders discover evil things happening in the village, by having the discovery made from within. Arguably the intentions of the cultists are not actually evil, but their methods definitely are. This scenario is atmospheric, contrasting the conservatism of village life with mad hopes and dreams of the cultists.
Perry Clask’s ‘Dead Letters from the Orchard’ is set in 1910, so not quite in the roleplaying game’s traditional period of the 1920s. Again it is a much longer scenario, but instead of exploring the tensions within a community, it explores those between two communities, particular racial tensions. When a series of unexplained and gruesome deaths occur in the African-American community of West Harper’s Orchard, followed by similar occurrences in the neighbouring white community of North Harper’s Orchard, suspicions are aroused and fingers are pointed. The Investigators are African Americans, residents of West Harper’s Orchard, who have had someone disappear and who are asked by John Harper, the man who gave the land upon which West Harper’s Orchard is built to investigate in order to prevent a further rise in tensions. The deaths appear to be linked to a series of letters sent out from North Harper’s Orchard, which makes the investigation there all more challenging given the social disparities of the day. Much of the scenario involves investigating the effects of the letters upon the Investigators’ community, literally Mythos-infused act of racism. The combination of some truly shocking scenes in the scenario and social attitudes of the period make ‘Dead Letters from the Orchard’ a challenge to both run and play. It is far from being a poor scenario, but it is a difficult one, and so the Keeper will need to approach this with care.
Lastly, ‘Mother of a Thousand Young’ by Poul Holmelund is set in 1953 and casts the Investigators as members of the police department of Groan, in smalltown USA. They are called out to look for a pair of teenagers who have gone missing from a sixteenth birthday party. One is the boyfriend of the girl whose birthday party it is and the other is the new girl in town. They left hand-in-hand, so the girl whose birthday party it is, is particularly angry. The trail leads to a bloody end when the boyfriend is found at the town’s lookout, naked, hanging from a tree, and eviscerated with his internal organs missing! It is a bloody start—though not as bloody as it should be—to the investigation and the condition of the body recalls a similar death five years earlier. Has the same killer struck again? Attempting to track down the missing girl quickly leads to the culprit, but whilst she escapes, the Investigators have a chance to work out what is truly going on before a final confrontation. The scenario has a great set-up and background, but feels shoehorned into a short playing time. This however, is not the main issue with it, and that is that it feels out of place in the anthology since its primary Mythos entity is not Shub-Niggurath. Not a bad scenario, but as consequence, it ends the scenario on a discordant note.
Physically, The Year of the Goat is well presented. The writing is good, the artwork and the handouts decent, and the cartography useable. It does need an edit in places. All of the scenarios are well organised with breakdowns of their various acts at the start to make preparing to run them that bit easier.
The question is, when is twelve scenarios focused on Shub-Niggurath too much? Undoubtedly, The Year of the Goat provides the Keeper with plenty of choice when it comes periods and settings, though not all of the settings served by Call of Cthulhu appear in the anthology. For example, there are no scenarios set in the Jazz Age or Ancient Rome. Similarly, there is plenty of choice in terms of the different aspects of ‘Black Goat of the Woods with a Thousand Young!’ that appear in the scenarios. Yet the fact that the twelve scenarios in The Year of the Goat are all one-shots combined with their theme, does limit their use. The best use of The Year of the Goat is as collection of one-shots or convention scenarios that the Keeper can occasionally consult and pick out one that she wants to run. Which would be worth it, because there are some good scenarios in the collection. ‘The Festival of the All-Mother’ is the standout because it calls for challenging roleplaying in a frighteningly contemporary situation, but ‘The Witch’s Bargain’ and ‘The Convent of Sancta Maria Lactans’ are also good, the latter in need of a sequel, if not a series of sequels.
Ultimately, the standout feature of The Year of the Goat is the combined effort upon the part of the participants and contributors to create the anthology. They should be applauded for that, but next time, their ambitions need to be aimed higher.