Miskatonic Monday #440: Fallen from the Farthest Star

Much like the Jonstown Compendium for RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha and The Companions of Arthur for material set in Greg Stafford’s masterpiece of Arthurian legend and romance, Pendragon, the Miskatonic Repository for Call of Cthulhu, Seventh Edition is a curated platform for user-made content. It is thus, “...a new way for creators to publish and distribute their own original Call of Cthulhu content including scenarios, settings, spells and more…” To support the endeavours of their creators, Chaosium has provided templates and art packs, both free to use, so that the resulting releases can look and feel as professional as possible. To support the efforts of these contributors, Miskatonic Monday is an occasional series of reviews which will in turn examine an item drawn from the depths of the Miskatonic Repository.

—oOo—

Their arrival in Olympia, the state capital of Washington State, on Monday, August 20th 1877, begins with a bang. Or rather several bangs. As one Native American passenger alights and is distracted down a side street by another, the remaining passengers aboard the stagecoach are subject to a hail of gunfire from the surrounding buildings. Native Olympians pull out their own handguns and shoot back, and when they manage to get out of the stagecoach to look, it appears that their assailants are also Native Americans. The exchange of fire quickly fizzles out and if any of the newly arrived passengers go after the shooters, they quickly find themselves lost in the back alleys and side streets of the city, and before they know it, a gun is in the small of their backs. Within moments the passengers, captured at gun point, find themselves whisked out of the city, as is the Native American who was beckoned to from down an alley. In the chaos, one of the female passengers is spirited away by some men with Russian accents. Anyone left at stagecoach, is approached by a scruffy, oddly mannered man, apologising for the attack, explaining that the Native American attackers are Squaxin, one of many Indian tribes who have long lived in the area of the Puget Sound and some of the tribes have strange secrets. One is a very strange secret indeed. Something important is hidden nearby and they would do anything to protect it. Others have recently arrived in the city of search of the secret in order to take for themselves. The man, who introduces himself as Elwood Candy, tells the passengers that he wants to find out for himself and his employers, but will not say who those employers are, except that they are not the US government.

This is the action-packed opening to Fallen from the Farthest Star. This is also the messy opening to Fallen from the Farthest Star. The scenario is for use with Down Darker Trails: Terrors of the Mythos in the Old West, the official Old West sourcebook for use with Call of Cthulhu, Seventh Edition. Action-packed because it opens with a shootout, but messy because it is written as a narrative and there is a lot going on. In fact, almost too much for the Keeper to track of. The result is overwhelming, and arguably, whilst it should be overwhelming for the players and their Investigators, the same should not be case for the Keeper. Unfortunately, this is no error upon the part of the author, but rather by design. The aim is actually to split the party and for each Investigator to interact with the different factions involved in the scenario, including two different groups of Native Americans, some Russians, and the strangely singular Elwood Candy. The aim is that all together, they will have a greater understanding of the situation they find themselves in, but only if they can get together and relate what has happened to them in the meantime. What this means is that Keeper will be running longer solo narratives for her players than she might ordinarily do so for a Call of Cthulhu scenario. In several of the situations, the kidnapped Investigators will be asked if they have ‘it’. Which they do not, and further, do not know what ‘it’ is. In fact, ‘it’ turns out to multiple things, but the fact that Fallen from the Farthest Star is a multi-MacGuffin, will again, not become apparent until the Investigators are brought together and can share what happened to them. All this requires a degree of acceptance by the players. The opening and set-up for the Investigators in Fallen from the Farthest Star is anything other than a traditional one for Call of Cthulhu and to high degree, the players and their Investigators are being railroaded.

From this point, the Keeper is going to be switching back forth between the Investigators and the groups that they are with. In some cases, the Investigators are held captive, in others they have more agency, but all have opportunity to interact an NPC or NPCs and gain some information pertinent to the situation. There is chance here too, for some good roleplaying. So, what is going on? The Native Americans are guardians to an ancient mind-bending artefact called the Star Egg, that fell from the sky thousands of years ago, split into two factions who cannot agree what to do with it; the Russians are dissidents turned archaeologists and treasure hunters looking for Spanish silver; and everyone else? They answer to their own masters! The Investigators are part of a prophecy said to tell of a growing threat to the Star egg and are asked for their help. As the different factions discover more of the information they need, they will make their way upriver and inland to the site where the Star Egg is hidden. The Investigators are the catalysts here, ultimately deciding how the scenario plays out and who comes out on top. There are a couple of wildcards thrown into this mix and they may influence what happens next. Along the way, there are some entertaining scenes, including one with the ‘Greatest Thief in the World’ and revelations ahoy as to who Elwood Candy’s true masters are and what they are prepared to tell the Investigators.

Besides the NPCs and Mythos monsters, the scenario is supported with information about Olympia, its history and surrounds, plus information about the Mythos tome, El Naufragio de Nuestra Señora de Loreto, that drives part of the story, the various devices that the Investigators might get their hands on, and the alien ship itself. These are nicely detailed. There is also a timeline for the scenario; maps of both Olympia and its surrounds—for both the players and the Keeper; and floorplans for the various locations. The floorplans are period pieces and do vary in quality. The handouts include the colourfully bizarre pictograms as well as NPC pictures (some of which look not a little familiar) and details of two pistols new to Down Darker Trails. Lastly there are six pre-generated Investigators. They consist of a Hispanic gunfighter, an aspiring artist, a soldier, a Native American cowboy, and a dilettante would-be writer. The aspiring artist previously appeared in The Schoolmarm’s Ghost.

Physically, Fallen from the Farthest Star is generally well presented. However, the writing is not as clear it could have been in parts and the artwork for the pictograms cartoonishly contrasts the rest of the scenario. That said, the NPC portraits are all period photographs, as are the maps and floorplans, and they do add a degree of verisimilitude. The floorplans could have been clearer though.

Ultimately, the problem with Fallen from the Farthest Star is the writing. There is a lot of context and background up front, including some decent advice about adapting the scenario to other periods, and a detailed—likely overly detailed—history and description of Washington state, Olympia, and nearby—it throws the Keeper into the action without much thought or advice as how the set-up, let alone the rest of the scenario is going to play out.

Ultimately, the problem with Fallen from the Farthest Star is the writing. There is a lot of context and background up front, including some decent advice about adapting the scenario to other periods, and a detailed—likely overly detailed—history and description of Washington state, Olympia, and nearby—it throws the Keeper into the action without much thought as how the set-up, let alone how the rest of the scenario is going to play out. It is not until after the shootout and its aftermath is there any advice for the Keeper, who is told that the next(!) “…[S]ection of the scenario might be a little confusing.” By this point it might be too late. There is no denying the ambition of Fallen from the Farthest Star, but it really going to need an experienced Keeper to run well with its multiple moving parts, and even then, said Keeper will need to pull some parts of the narrative—the gunfight at the start of the scenario, in particular—apart and put them back together to her satisfaction to have them work effectively.

Friday Fantasy: Inferno Road

Hell rocks with rage and the race never ends! An enormous Doom Buggy roars across the foul and sulphurous landscape, its great steel-plated wheels smashing the smaller vehicle that swarm around, crushing flat boulders, crags, and fissures, cracking the bone dry surface from which first black blood spurts and then seeps. Atop is Satan, the Lord of Darkness, the Greater Deceiver, and the Master of the Nine Levels of Hell. But Master no longer, for he is chained and can only scream out his pain and frustration at his betrayal. Screams that cause the demons and devils that the work the great vehicle to cackle and the drivers of the convoy that chases in its wake—Killcycles, Motor Devils, Succubi on Unicycles, and more, to urge themselves to driver faster, faster, faster. As Satan shakes his chains and the whole of Hell shakes, the Dark Lords, his Princes see this as an opportunity. A chance to prove their loyalty? A chance to supplant their former master? No matter what their aim and their ambition, they have a ready supply of proxies—soulless grubs endlessly churning and writhing in the burning pits of Hell. Only each grub knows or cares how long it has been there, but what they all share is a constant, agonising desire for a Soul! Any Soul! Even if it was not a Soul that was theirs. Each of the Princes of Hell reaches down and scoops up grubs and after imbuing them with past lives, throws them into the convoy chasing after the Doom Buggy!

This is the setting for Inferno Road, a race and a chase scenario Goodman Games’ Dungeon Crawl Classics Role Playing Game. It comes from the same team behind The Hobonomicon and again, is a showcase for the art of Doug Kovacs. This has ramifications for how easy Inferno Road is to use, since there is more art than text and that leaves the scenario with much less direction—other than onwards across the plains of Hell—in terms of running it. It should be no surprise that the players take the roles of the Grubs scooped up by their Princes of Hell and thrown into the chase. Each Grub has the traditional six stats of Dungeon Crawl Classics, some Hit Points, and two past lives. The latter are nearest thing that Inferno Road has to skills and the Judge might grant bonuses if a player can bring an aspect of them into play. However, once per game, a Grub can manifest an item pertaining to a past life. A Grub’s Prince of Hell is its Patron.

One thing to note is that some of the Past Lives are dark, even horrifying, in nature and veer towards the tasteless, if not cross that line for some players. Of course, Inferno Road is set in Hell and the Past Lives reflect that, each one of them having committed sins and other actions that resulted in their Soul being cast into Hell. Some require some invention upon the part of the players, but others are suggestive, and some are actually overt as what those sins might have been. For example, ‘Manson Family Member’, ‘Sex Criminal’, and ‘Nazi Stormtrooper’. With these, Inferno Road does cross the line because of what they ask the player to think about and then bring elements of that into play, the Judge might also want to decide which of the Past Lives that she wants to include right from the start. Ultimately, it up to the players at the table how far such sins and what the Past Lives did is expressed at the table and brought into play. What it makes clear though, is that as silly as its set-up is, Inferno Road is an adult scenario, one that in this instance deserves the advice it gives of ‘Trigger Warning: Everything’.

Just Another Grub
Strength 12 Agility 16 (+2) Stamina 7 (-1)
Personality 11 Intelligence 11 Luck 10
Hit Points: 6
Past Lives: Canadian Immigrant, Dog

From this simple set of stats, it suggests that Inferno Road is a ‘Character Funnel’. This is a singular feature to the Dungeon Crawl Classics Role Playing Game, which takes Zero Level Player Characters—usually four per player—and pushes them through a Zero Level dungeon. Devoid of the abilities, spells, combat acumen, and Hit Points that a Class would grant them, a Player Character in a ‘Character Funnel’, must instead upon his luck and his wits, all whilst aspiring to a proper Class. In Inferno Road, the Grubs seek not treasure, but Souls—and everything has a Soul. Kill another creature and a Grub can harvest its Soul and if aboard or close to the Doom Buggy, it knows where the nearest and biggest pile of Souls is. When a Grub harvests a Soul, it can either eat the Soul or add it to its Luck. Eating a Soul is really how a Grub gets better. Consume a Soul and a Grub will transform into an Arachnodaemon, Brute, Harpy, Killcycle, Motor Devil, Pit Imp, Spiny Devil, Succubus (Type I), Succubus (Type II), Twins, and so on. He can also regress back into a Grub. All of this is randomly determined.

Bar the set-up, almost everything in Inferno Road is randomly determined and thus supported by several sets of tables and the means to generate various aspects of the game. This includes the means to generate Hell Princes, Upgrades to the Player Characters, vehicles in the convoy chasing the Doom Buggy, and random crew and miniboss features. Separate sheets provide charts of random stuff and things to find on the way, and infernal weapons. The Spinner is used to indicate what new form that a Grub, or the Grub in its current form, transforms into, but there is a simple table included if the Judge simply wants to roll on that. It is also possible for a Grub to roll its current form and get Upgrades instead.

What Inferno Road does not provide is any guidance on running it. It does not explain how to set it up or what to do from turn to turn. The Judge has to infer a lot from reading Inferno Road and then set it up from that. It is not necessarily difficult, but it is made all the more challenging because of the lack of advice. And further, it means that Inferno Road is definitely not for the inexperienced Judge.

Physically, Inferno Road is a great looking book. Doug Kovacs’ artwork is as good as you expect it to be and it is clear that he is having fun drawing for a project of his own rather than a commission. Inferno Road does need an edit in places though.

Ultimately, Inferno Road is more of a set-up and then work it out how you want to run kind of thing. It is not so much a ‘Character Funnel’ with Zero Level Grubs as a ‘Character Grinder’ since there is no conclusion to Inferno Road, no end to its ‘Hieronymus Bosch meets Mad Max 2’ grind of road rage and high demonic action. What its set-up is designed for is a convention event with multiple players passing by, dropping in to play, and dropping out again as the Judge keeps the churn of Grubs and the Doom Buggy rollin’ rollin’ rollin’… Inferno Road looks good and sounds great, but like any demon pact, the Judge really has to have a very good idea of what she is getting into and what she wants out of it.

Inland Innsmouth

You awake slowly, reaching through the murk of a befogged mind, guided by the sound of a bell. A constant sound. You are cold, it is night, and you are barefoot, just like the men and women standing around you. All dressed the same. Nightgowns. Eyes staring wide. You do not know who you are, but you know you are in Oakwood Springs, a sanitorium for the wealthy in the retreat town of Lake Geneva, though you are not quite sure why. You recall being questioned. Was it about what ailment or condition that besets you, or was not something else? You are not sure. The orderlies snap at you to return to your rooms, but unlike your fellow patients, whose faces only show bewilderment at being roused from their bed at this time of night, the look in the orderlies is one of fear. Why are you in Oakwood Springs? Are you sick or simply need rest? And just what is that the orderlies are afraid of?

This is the set-up for the Madness at Geneva Lake: A Call of Cthulhu Adventure. It is the second convention scenario to be published by Chaosium, Inc. for Call of Cthulhu, Seventh Edition, the other being The Shadow Over Providence. Where that scenario is set during the roleplaying game’s classic period of the nineteen twenties, this scenario is set in December 1891—for a very good reason—and thus could be run using Cthulhu by Gaslight. However, Madness at Geneva Lake is just a little special. It was published for Gary Con XVII, the convention that celebrates the life of E. Gary Gygax, in conjunction with Gygax Ink, to celebrate the fiftieth anniversary of Chaosium, Inc. It takes place in Lake Geneva, the Wisconsin town where E. Gary Gygax grew up, where TSR, Inc. was based, and where Gary Con is held each year. Lake Geneva stands on Geneva Lake and beginning at the end of the nineteenth century, was renowned as a resort town and retreat for the wealthy from Chicago to the east. Here the socialites would spend their summers and perhaps when they needed long term medical rest or treatment, months in the town’s expensive sanatoriums, receiving the most expensive medical care that money could buy.

However, times have changed in Lake Geneva. Winter has drawn in and as crisp snow lies on the ground, thick fog rolls in off the lake. Many of the visitors to the town, expecting to enjoy an excursion aboard one of the steamers, have returned to shore, touched and disturbed by a dread presence lurking in the icy depths of the lake. Is this why the Investigators are in Oakwood Springs?

The thrust of Madness at Geneva Lake: A Call of Cthulhu Adventure is quite simple. Cultists are attempting to summon something nasty, in this case from Geneva Lake. For veteran players of Call of Cthulhu, the identity of the cultists should be a surprise this far from the coast, being a mixture of Deep Ones and Deep One Hybrids as well as ordinary cultists. Actually, there are two factions of cultists involved in the whole affair, but the fact that there are two factions is unlikely to become apparent to the Investigators.

The scenario is divided into two acts. In the first act, the Investigators need to find why they are in Oakwood Springs, find their belongings, examine their patient records, and then escape the sanitorium. The emphasis is upon stealth, trying to get past the orderlies and the nightwatchmen, and attempting to get into the sanitorium’s various locked rooms. One of the pre-generated Investigators does have the Locksmith skill, so he will be useful, but in the main the Investigators will need to find the keys. All this whilst sleepwalking patients try to stagger out of the front door into the fog where things lurk, and towards Geneva Lake. The atmosphere in the sanitorium is creepy and tense, and this will grow and grow as the Investigators determine who they are and what they know. Despite the atmosphere in the sanitorium and despite the feeling that they are trapped, the Investigators are not truly in danger in the sanitorium. Further, they even have help in their attempts to escape.

The second act of Madness at Geneva Lake: A Call of Cthulhu Adventure begins with the Investigators having found out who they are and what they know, escaped from Oakwood Springs, and learned that the source of everyone’s anxiety and terror lies on Geneva Lake, and is tied to a well known paddle steamer, the Lucius Newberry. This is described as one of Lake Geneva’s more exquisite sidewheelers, “complete with a luxurious decor that included crystal, brass and polished fixtures, and even oil paintings.” The scenario should ideally culminate aboard the vessel, with the Investigators confronting a betentacled abomination and preventing a vile ritual. Amusingly, the best solution given is to set the ship alight and burn it down to the waterline. This is because the Lucius Newberry actually did catch fire in December 1891 and sink, and that in 1982, TSR, Inc. actually funded a salvage attempt on the recently discovered wreck of the vessel.

Over half of Madness at Geneva Lake: A Call of Cthulhu Adventure is dedicated to six appendices. These include all of the scenario’s adversaries and monsters, a dark history of both Lake Geneva and Geneva Lake, handouts, seven pre-generated Investigators, new spells, and details of Lake Geneva’s sanitoriums. The pre-generated Investigators all come with male and female options, but they do include a ‘brain in a jar’ capable of casting spells; a Deep One Hybrid; an archaeologist; a member of the clergy; a journalist and photographer; a private investigator; and a scientist. The ‘brain in a jar’ will present a roleplaying challenge, but integrating it into the scenario is likely to be more challenging.

Physically, Madness at Geneva Lake: A Call of Cthulhu Adventure is cleanly and tidily presented. The artwork is good, the cartography serviceable, and the handouts nicely done. However, the scenario does need another edit.

The scenario is short and serviceable, with a twist or two as well as an initial emphasis on stealth and investigation, which will satisfy veteran players of Call of Cthulhu. It is designed for convention play, so it misses an opportunity to really roleplay the recovery of the Investigators’ memories and their treatment at Oakwood Springs, and the shortness means that the true nature of the villains in the sanitorium never get a chance to come to the fore. Nevertheless, Madness at Geneva Lake: A Call of Cthulhu Adventure takes the classic set-up of amnesiac protagonists and being confined in a sanitorium and gives it a fast-paced spin through some roleplaying adjacent history!

Crime at Christmas

It is the time of year when a man’s mind turns to murder. Not because he have had enough of his family and his relatives for one year—and just in one day—but because it is traditional to enjoy murder mysteries, whether on the page or one the screen. And of course, such murders should be as cozy as possible. Then, if that murder is cozy, the detectives need to be equally as cozy. When not cooing and aahing over the very latest tragic death that has occurred under their noses, they like attending to their gardens, participating in the Women’s Institute, reading the next title to discuss as part of their book club, knitting something suitable for a grandniece or nephew, organising the next village fete, and singing in the church choir. These are the Matrons of Mystery, older ladies of leisure whose surreptitious and unobtrusive nature means that they get overlooked when investigating crimes and searching for clues, and eventually putting together a solution which unmasks the perpetrator! Matrons of Mystery is an investigative roleplaying game in which there are mysteries and there are clues to be uncovered, but there is no set solution. And if the Matrons do not get quite get their solution right the first time, they can investigate further and propose another solution!This is what Matrons of Mystery: A cozy mystery roleplaying game—and Brindlewood Bay, the roleplaying game by Jason Cordova it is derived from—both do.

Christmas Crime: Three festive mysteries for Matrons of Mystery presents three more mysteries for the Matrons to solve, but all with a Christmas theme. Each of the three comes with a description of the theme, sets the scene with a set-up, details of the victim, suggests ways in which the Matrons can get involved, and the Teaser, essentially that scene before the opening credits when everyone’s obvious relationships are established and then the dead body of the murder victim is dramatically revealed (cue dramatic music!). This is followed by seven or eight possible suspects, each with a description and reason to want to murder the victim. Lastly there is a lengthy list of clues to be found.

The trilogy starts with ‘Oh No They Didn’t’, which opens with the dress rehearsal for the village amateur dramatics society’s annual Christmas pantomime at the village hall coming to an abrupt halt when Willow Jackson, the lovely young actress playing the lead role of Cinderella, is found lying in the middle of the stage in a pool of blood! Ideally, one of the Matrons should be playing the role of the Fairy Godmother, but the murder mystery suggests other roles too. The second mystery, ‘Bake or Death’, takes place at the village’s annual baking contest with three contests being of note—best mince pie, best biscuit, and best cake. Of these, the best cake competition is subject to the fiercest rivalries. The victim is Lisa Monroe, relative newcomer to the villager and winner of the contest three years in a row. Unfortunately, she is unlikely to winner a fourth time after she is found dead with a cake ribbon wrapped around her neck! The Matrons can be the Judges, contestants, or the organisers. The trio comes to a close with ‘Slay Ride’ in which Bob Chandler, the owner of the local stable yard, who every year plays Santa Claus and provides a carriage as Father Christmas’ sleigh for the village Christmas fete, is found dead in the stables. The Matrons can be organisers of the fete, friends of Bob Chandler, or simply like horses. The teaser as a somewhat gruesome tone when it turns out that Rudolph the Horse’s nose is not red simply because, but because it has something red on it…*

* “Why Rudolph, you’ve got red on you.”

All three cases, the various suspects have secrets and reasons to kill the respective victims. Most of them are not all that nice and all of them are rampant stereotypes typical of the genre. So, there is scope aplenty here for the Game Master to ham up her portrayal of the NPCs, since these episodes—as per the genre—is being broadcast in the middle of the afternoon or the middle of the evening, the perfect cozy, easy spots for the genre. Further, the mysteries themselves are stereotypical, even clichés, of the genre. Or rather as they are properly called, classics. What lifts these classics up above the ordinary is the fact that there is not set solution to the murders. The players and their Matrons can discover the clues, question the suspects, verify alibis, and deduce the identity of the culprit and his or her motivations, and in the process provide a comfortably cozy entertainment, whilst the Game Master gets to portray a cast riddled with jealousies, insecurities, and secrets. Plus, just like the cozy murder mysteries themselves, the murder mysteries in Christmas Crime are just as undemanding when it comes to set-up.

Physically, Christmas Crime is neatly and tidily laid out. It is not illustrated bar the Christmasy front cover. The only that it lacking is some locations for the mysteries to play out in, but the Game Master and her players should be able to improvise those.

What could be cozier than death at Christmas, than the comfortable clichés and mild murders of Christmas Crime: Three festive mysteries for Matrons of Mystery?

Mavens of Murder

The mystery—as opposed to the mysterious, which has always been there—has long been a part of roleplaying, all the way back to The Maltese Clue, the scenario published by Judges Guild in 1979.  It really came to the fore with roleplaying games like Call of Cthulhu, Gangbusters, and Justice, Inc. and more recently seen in the GUMSHOE System with roleplaying games such as Mutant City Blues, which combines superheroes with the police procedural. What these all do with the mystery is provide the Game Matron with a plot and a set of clues that the players and their characters investigate the mystery and hopefully piece together the clues to uncover the mystery. However, what if the mystery and its investigation was set up the other way around? What if there was no set solution and instead the solution to the mystery could be constructed from the clues uncovered by the players and their characters and would be, if not absolutely correct, then very nearly so? This is what Matrons of Mystery—and Brindlewood Bay, the roleplaying game by Jason Cordova it is derived from—both do.

Both Matrons of Mystery and Brindlewood Bay are Powered by the Apocalypse roleplaying games in which players take the roles of women of a certain age who investigate murder—often much to the consternation of local law enforcement. Brindlewood Bay has an American feel and behind the series of murders a Lovecraftian conspiracy, whereas Matrons of Mystery focuses entirely on the murder mysteries, employs a parred back version of the Powered by the Apocalypse mechanics, and has a decidedly British sensibility being inspired by television series such as Miss Marple, Rosemary & Thyme, Agatha Raisin, Queens of Mystery, Father Brown, and so on. This is not the world of the hardboiled mystery, or even mystery on a medium heat, but that of the ‘cozy’ mystery, set in a small town or village where everyone knows everyone—except that recently arrived stranger, and of course, everyone’s secrets—and there is a strong sense of community, and is of course, suitable for afternoon or Sunday night viewing with all of the family gathered round the television.

Matrons of Mystery: A cozy mystery roleplaying game is designed for three or four players, plus the Game Matron, and each mystery ideally takes a session to solve. This makes it good for one shots or convention games, and the familiarity of its genre means that Matrons of Mystery will be easy to grasp and familiar to most players. In Matrons of Mystery, players take the roles of ladies of a certain age, who are perhaps single, widowed, or divorced, certainly retired or have more than enough time to throw themselves into their community and various activities and charities. For example, keeping the parish church clean, attending meetings of the W.I., helping run Meals on Wheels, doing the village Christmas Pantomime, and so on. Of course, when murder strikes—as it invariably does in their surprisingly high murder count communities—it is the ‘Matrons of Mystery’ who take up their handbags, put down their trowels, and ever ready to make a nice hot cup of tea, discover whodunnit before the local bobby on the beat, Police Constable Plodd, and Inspector Witless from the nearest big town, can work it all out.

Character generation and game set-up in Matrons of Mystery is quite quick. First, the players name and decide on some details about their Matrons’ village. Then, every Matron has a name, a Personal Style, a Hobby, a Background, an Investigation Style, and a Contact. So a Name might be Audrey or Nettie, a Personal Style could be ‘Smart and Classic’, ‘Punk’, or ‘Twinset and Pearl’, and a Hobby Baking, Gardening, Collecting, or Amateur Dramatics. The Background consists of answers to three questions—the first is about a Matron’s former partner or whether or not she was married, what was her career before she retired, and whether she has any children, or if not, young relatives she is fond of. Her Investigation Style—Physical, Logical, Intuitive, or Gregarious—represents different approaches to solving mysteries, and the Contact is someone that the Matron knows well from her past and can rely upon to help out in a pinch. To create a Matron, a player decides upon all of these factors, answers the three questions for her Background, and then assigns +2 to her primary Investigation Style, +1 to her secondary Investigation Style, sets a third at 0, and assigns -1 to her least favoured Investigation Style.

Henrietta Wyndham
Personal Style: Punk
Hobby: Painting
Background: Divorced (to Nigel Wyndham, Stage name: Nasty Nigel), Former Record Producer, Children include Freddy, Pandora, Ned
Contact: Gordon Blythe-White (Record Exec)
Physical 0 Logical -1 Intuitive +1 Gregarious +2

Mechanically, Matrons of Mystery uses Powered by the Apocalypse. To undertake an action or ‘Move’, a player rolls two six-sided dice, adds his Matron’s Investigative Style and aims to roll high. The results fall into the ‘Yes’, ‘Yes, but…’, and ‘No and…’ Roll ten and more and the Move is successful; roll between seven and nine, and the Move is successful, but comes with a Complication; and roll six or less, and the Move not only fails, but adds a Complication. A Complication hinders the Matron’s investigative efforts, such as her slipping and injuring herself climbing in or out of a window or the suspect taking umbrage at one or more of the questions posed to him. This can lead to an ongoing Condition, such as a sprained ankle or being thrown out of a society dinner. (If there is one issue with Matrons of Mystery, it is that it could have done with a bigger list of Complications and especially Conditions to inspire the Game Matron.)

Rules are provided for gaining Experience Points and either using them in play to improve dice rolls or saving them to improve a Matron’s Investigative Styles. They do feel optional though.

Unlike most versions of Powered by the Apocalypse, the rules in Matrons of Mystery include an Advantage and Disadvantage mechanic. Thus when a Matron has the Advantage, which can come from her Personal Style, Hobby, Background, or the situation, three six-sided dice are rolled instead of two, and the best used. Conversely, when she is at a Disadvantage, her player rolls three dice and keeps the lowest two. Another difference between other roleplaying games using Powered by the Apocalypse and Matrons of Mystery is that it does not make use of Playbooks, each of which provide an archetypal character and its associated Moves. Instead, Matrons of Mystery provides a standard set of nine Moves that all of the Matrons can use. The first five Moves—‘Investigate’, ‘Interrogate’, ‘Take Action’, ‘Lend A Hand’, and ‘Ask A Favour’ are used to gain clues and conduct the Investigation. The next three, ‘Reminisce’, ‘Nice Cup of Tea and a Sit Down’, and ‘Go To Adverts’, enforce both the genre and the format of the genre. ‘Reminisce’ enables a Matron to recall something from her past which will help with the current investigation; ‘Nice Cup of Tea and a Sit Down’ lets two or more Matrons sit down, have a nice hot cup of tea, have a chat with each other, and in doing so, each remove a single Condition; and ‘Go To Adverts’ enforces a break in the story when a Matron is in danger, ends the scene on a cliffhanger, and lets the players discuss how the cliffhanger is resolved with the imperilled Matron unharmed when the adverts end!

The final Move is ‘Put It All Together’. This happens at the end or near the end of the game when the Matrons gather their collected clues and deduce the identity of the murderer. Instead of using an Investigative Style to modify the roll, the player uses the number of clues and secrets found out so far, minus the number of suspects involved in the murder. Typically, there are eight suspects per murder, so the Matrons will need to have gathered at least eight clues and secrets to negate this, plus more to gain a modifier to the roll. Roll ten or more and the Move is successful, the Matrons are correct in their deductions and have identified the Murderer and his motive; roll between seven and nine, and the Move is successful, the Matrons are correct in their deductions and have identified the Murderer and his motive, but there a Complication which the Matrons will need to overcome in order to apprehend the Murderer; and roll six or less, and the Move fails, indicating that the Matron’s deductions are incorrect. The Game Matron has to explain why and then sends the Matrons back off to continue their investigations and try again.

For the Game Matron, there is good advice on designing a mystery, from the theme and the set-up through to defining the secrets and listing the clues. There is also good advice on running the game—both online and at the gaming table, how to handle clues, secrets, Complications and Conditions, and so on, as well as optional rules for one-on-one play and playing away from the Matrons’ home village. A short bibliography provides some inspiration for the Game Matron. Then there are three ready-to-play Mysteries, complete with set-up, teaser, eight suspects, and a long list of clues. The first is ‘Gardner’s Question Crime’ in which the village hosts the popular radio show, Gardeners’ Answers in the grounds of Hatherly Hall. With most of the village present, the guest speaker, celebrity gardener and host of the television series, Gardener’s Life, Alan Jefferson, drops dead as he is about to take to the stage. This is followed by ‘Dicing With Death’ in which the village hosts a roleplaying convention (!) and award-winning game designer, Scott Sallow, is found dead on the last day of the convention with his mouth stuffed full of polyhedrals! Lastly, ‘Ding Dong Death’ is takes place just before national bell ringing championships and with the village wanting to put on a good performance, the bell ringing team is getting in some last-minute practice. Unfortunately, the lead bell ringer, Walter Bell, is found hanging upside down from one of the bell ropes. All three scenarios are great set-ups, though ‘Dicing With Death’ feels both improbable and a direct appeal to its intended audience.

Physically, Matrons of Mystery is a tidily done digest-sized book. The cover is appropriately rural, whilst the internal artwork, all publicly sourced, is there to break up the page rather than necessarily illustrate the game. The book is well written and easy to read—especially with the slightly larger fount size.

Matrons of Mystery is fun to play and it is simple to play. Having just the one set of nine Basic Moves eases play no end. Given the age of the Matrons, it is much more of a social game than physical game necessarily, although some sneaking around is probably going to be necessary and perfectly in keeping with the genre. Although it does present her with eight suspects to roleplay, the lighter nature of the rules do provide the Game Matron with the opportunity to really focus on her roleplaying and have fun with it too. The nature of the game and its ‘no given perpetrator’ set-up also strips Matrons of Mystery of any sense of stress or competition which might arise in the players and the Game Matron as they worry whether their deductions and solution to the crime is actually right. Instead, the players and their Matrons construct the murder solution and motive from the clues, thus emphasising storytelling—both the storytelling of the murder and the storytelling of it being solved.

Matrons of Mystery: A cozy mystery roleplaying game is cleverly cozy, taking the structure of Brindlewood Bay and parring it back to focus on its core game play. It is a smart, sprightly roleplaying game which delightfully evokes its genre from the page to the table. And if you are going to play this at the table, a nice hot cup of tea is an absolute necessity.

A Symbaroum Duology III

Adventure Pack 4 is the latest in series of ongoing scenario duologies for Symbaroum, the near-Dark Ages fantasy roleplaying game from Swedish publisher, Free League Publishing. From The Copper Crown to Adventure Pack 3, these duologies provide scenarios which place in and around the events of the Chronicle of the Throne of Thorns campaign, but which are standalone and are so easier to add to a Game Master’s own campaign.  Adventure Pack 4 itself presents two scenarios which highlight the internal strife and factional rivalry which runs through the young kingdom of Ambria. ‘Call of the Dark’ takes the Player Characters south and back into the northern territories on the very edge of the Lost Land of Alberetor in the company of a lowborn noble who is looking to recover proof as to the status of her family, whilst ‘Retribution’ begins with a hunt for a missing person in the city of Kurun before dropping the Player Characters into a conspiracy to antagonise relationships between Ambria and the Barbarian Clans.

Both of the scenarios in Adventure Pack 4 make use of content from the Advanced Player’s Guide and are designed for Player Characters between the levels of Experienced and Veteran, roughly one hundred Experience Points. Each consists of a three-act affair, plus a thorough introduction and timeline which explains what is going on and how to get the Player Characters involved. Each should take several sessions to play through and comes richly appointed with decent maps, some nice handouts, and not just their own background, but details that also add to the wider world of Symbaroum. Given their nature and setting, neither of these scenarios is suited to beginning characters or players, and both the Game Master and her players with some experience of the mechanics and setting will get the most enjoyment from them. 

‘Call of the Dark’ highlights the precarious existence of some of the minor noble houses in Ambria with limited land to hold as fiefdoms and in some cases, the inability to prove their right to be on the Nobility Register. In most cases, this is because such records were left behind or lost in the flight from Alberetor. House Sarli is one such noble house and in order to prove its rightful status, mounts an expedition to its ancestral lands back in Alberetor. The Player Characters are hired to help with the expedition, and in joining the expedition, ‘Call of the Dark’ will see them returning back to the site of their and their players’ first adventures in Symbaroum with ‘The Promised Land’. Thus they find themselves at camp just south of the Titans, the mountain range which separates Ambria from Alberetor. Here though, their aim is not to go north into the safety of a kingdom untouched by blight, but south into a land blighted by The Great War with the lords of the dead. Fortunately, their destination lies in the very north of the fallen kingdom, on the edge of the Blight, though this does not mean that the Player Characters will necessarily escape its corruptive influence…

Setting out from the Cliff of Korinda, the refugee camp in the southern foothills of the Titans, the expedition skirt the edge of the mountains and search the remains of the fiefdom for the necessary proof. In the process they will uncover family secrets, horrors from the past, and secrets which threaten to undermine current religious orthodoxy in Ambria—and beyond. The refugee camp is nicely detailed, as is each of the various locations within the House Sarli fiefdom. Throughout there is a strong sense of loss, desolation, and abandonment, whether that is in the once thriving, but now abandoned buildings in the fiefdom or the dreary state of the few remaining occupants of the region. Although the expedition, and thus the Player Characters, are free to explore the Sarli lands, there are several locations their employer wants to visit, so the likelihood is that they will do them in the order as written. This is no bad thing, since it both builds the story whilst engaging the Player Characters in discrete encounters, whether that is with a garrison of undead soldiers still driven to perform their duties in life despite their nature, a nasty monster hunting underground, and more. Although its plot is quite simple on the surface, there is actually quite a bit going on behind its scenes, and the Game Master will need to bring that out as play progresses for her players to get the most out of what is a very enjoyable adventure.

‘Call of the Dark’ gives the Player Characters the opportunity to do something different—that is, visit old Alberetor, if only the very outskirts. For two of Symbaroum’s character types, it also provides opportunities to explore their backgrounds. One is the Noble, who could actually replace the representative of House Sarli and thus make the adventure that much more personal. The other is a theurg of the sun god, Prios, who is likely to have his beliefs tested—physically and theologically! Overall, this is a thoroughly enjoyable if mournful adventure with lots of nods to previous adventures which is best run later in a campaign.

The second scenario, ‘Retribution’, takes place in Ambria, specifically the city of Kurun, the seat of the Duke of Berakka located to the west of Thistle Hold, the town from which many a treasure hunter’s fortune or failure has been launched into the Davokar Forest. It is a classic tale of unrequited and misplaced love which festers from resentment into revenge and given that it is written for Symbaroum, that revenge is dark and bloody! Set across five hills divided by a river which makes Kurun an important shipping port, the city itself is described in some detail such that a Game Master could easily have her campaign revisit it, and in addition to detailing its factions and notable establishments, provides a trio of adventure seeds to support that.

Where the emphasis in ‘Call of the Dark’ is on exploration and interaction, the emphasis in ‘Retribution’ is on investigation and interaction. This is a classic investigative scenario as one clue leads to another and a missing persons case leads into another missing persons case, and then a much bigger story. The players will have to work hard with their roleplaying to discover what is going on as the investigation moves from the low-class, even criminal parts of Kurun to its upper echelons and back again, taking in a tribe of Goblin exiles on the make and an increasingly dangerous response to the Player Characters’ activities as they digger deeper and deeper into the mystery. Ultimately, they should discover what lies at the heart of the mystery, which can lead to a very different third act. It all depends on what the Player Characters decide to do with the information they have discovered. Simply asking for help or leaving it for the authorities to deal with and the events play out without the Player Characters’ intervention. This is not only disastrous for all concerned as the plot the Player Characters were investigating comes to fruition, but it also truncates the scenario by a third. Simply, the players and their characters very much have to be proactive and certainly self-motivated to want to enter the third act, but if they do, the Player Characters have a desperate journey across country to make to stop the villains’ plans coming to fruition, all the while harried by the enemies they have made along the way. If they are in time, the Player Characters have a chance to save the day, if not, they may be able to stop their enemies’ plans from progressing any further, but the damage will most certainly have been done. The third act is then, a race against time, decently handled with sufficient detail to keep up both pace and flavour. Even if the Player Characters do race across the countryside they may not be necessarily in time and disaster can still ensue—so there is a higher chance of player failure with the scenario. Nevertheless, ‘Retribution’ does a fine job of taking its theme of unrequited love and giving a very dark Symbaroum twist and ultimately injecting it with the Blight and its corruptive influence.

In addition to the scenarios, Adventure Pack 4 is rounded out with an appendix of new rules, editions, artefacts, and more. The new rules cover ‘The Dangers of the Darkened Land’, the continuing effect of the corruption which has blackened Alberetor, ‘Forced Ride’, which handles continued horse rides over long distances in as short a time as possible, ‘Sleep Deprivation’, and more. Many of these rules, such as those for ‘Forced Ride’ or the ‘Bushcraft’ Ability, either replace or expand earlier rules, and most of them feature in one or the other of the two scenarios. Lastly, there are four new artefacts, and five handouts and nine maps for the players, all of the latter unnumbered.

Physically, Adventure Pack 4 is as well presented as you would expect for a Symbaroum supplement, done in full colour with atmospheric artwork and excellent maps. The handouts for the players are also good, though it would have been useful if the NPC thumbnails had been reproduced for player presentation. Similarly, despite the relative slimness of the book, an index would have been useful too.

Both of the scenarios in Adventure Pack 4 highlight that there is a lot going on elsewhere in Ambria and beyond than the continuing story of ‘The Chronicle of the Throne of Thorns’. However, both scenarios come with a lot of backstory and background which the Player Characters are unlikely to really uncover in their entirety, but which the Game Master will still need to digest and present to them should they need to know immediately, or they decide to dig into that background as much as they are able. This is especially the case with ‘Call of the Dark’, whether that is politics back in Ambria or in countries elsewhere on the continent which are barely touched upon by the Symbaroum line. There is potential for the Player Characters to explore some of this, but that would require no little development upon the part of the Game Master. In the case of ‘Call of the Dark’ this would work well if the scenario’s main NPC has been replaced by a Player Character. Adventure Pack 4 is worth coming back to once both scenarios have been played though, especially the scenario ‘Retribution’ as the consequences of its events—whether the Player Characters succeed or not, are likely to have greater ramifications for a campaign (that is, unless the Player Character replaces the NPC in ‘Call of the Dark’). The presentation of Kurun in ‘Retribution’ makes it as potentially as interesting a location as Thistle Hold nearby and its inclusion adds more to the setting.

For  all the complexities of their respective backgrounds, the two adventures in Adventure Pack 4 are not necessarily as complex to run. In the case of ‘Call of the Dark’ there is something joyously simple to the plot of its adventure—at least on the surface, and ‘Retribution’ feels like a classic Film Noir plot done for Symbaroum. In terms of theme and setting, the scenarios in Adventure Pack 4 are very nicely done and will be a lot of fun to run and play later in a campaign.

Tomb of the Warden

Doom on the Warden is a scenario for Metamorphosis Alpha: Fantastic Role-Playing Game of Science Fiction Adventures on a Lost Starship. The first Science Fiction roleplaying game and the first post-apocalypse roleplaying game, Metamorphosis Alpha is set aboard the Starship Warden, a generation spaceship which has suffered an unknown catastrophic event which killed the crew and most of the million or so colonists, and left the ship irradiated and many of the survivors and the flora and fauna aboard mutated. Some three centuries later, as Humans, Mutated Humans, Mutated Animals, and Mutated Plants, the Player Characters, knowing nothing of their captive universe, would leave their village to explore strange realm around them, wielding fantastic mutant powers and discovering how to make use of the fantastic devices of the gods and the ancients that is technology, and ultimately learn of their enclosed world. Originally published in 1976, it would go on to influence a whole genre of roleplaying games, starting with Gamma World, right down to Mutant Crawl Classics Roleplaying Game – Triumph & Technology Won by Mutants & Magic from Goodman Games. And it would be Goodman Games which brought the roleplaying game back with the stunning Metamorphosis Alpha Collector’s Edition in 2016, and support the forty-year old roleplaying game with a number of supplements, many which would be collected in the ‘Metamorphosis Alpha Treasure Chest’.

Published following a successful Kickstarter campaign, Doom on the Warden is a special scenario. Written by James M. Ward, the designer of Metamorphosis Alpha, it is intended to be played using between six and eight characters with plenty of play experience behind them and plenty of scavenged equipment and artefacts. It can be played as a convention scenario and there are guidelines towards that end, but Doom on the Warden is definitely a scenario which experienced and long-time players of Metamorphosis Alpha will get the most out of. This is primarily for three reasons and why the scenario is so special. First, the scenario takes place on the fabled Level Zero, the equivalent of a lost Xanadu or Atlantis where some, all, or even none of the answers might be found as to exactly what is going on aboard the Starship Warden. Second, in exploring this Level Zero and discovering its secrets, one potential outcome is that Doom on the Warden could set the Game Master’s campaign on an entirely different course—literally and figuratively. Third, Doom on the Warden is inspired by another scenario all together—S1 Tomb of Horrors.

Published in 1978, and more recently in the 2013 Dungeons of Dread and Tales from the Yawning Portal from 2017, S1, Tomb of Horrors was designed by E. Gary Gygax and has always had the reputation of being the ultimate ‘Deathtrap Dungeon’, being filled with puzzles and traps which when combined with a seeming random factor makes it a challenge that is almost impossible to beat. It would be reprinted multiple times, receive a boxed sequel in the form of Return to the Tomb of Horrors, and its legendary status would ensure that it appeared at number three in Dungeon #116’s “30 Greatest D&D Adventures of All Time” (November, 2004). S1 Tomb of Horrors was always intended to present a challenge to the most experienced of players and James M. Ward has taken the same approach to Doom on the Warden. It is designed to challenge the players of Science Fiction roleplaying games, presenting difficult situations and fearsome opponents, but is different to S1, Tomb of Horrors in a number of ways. Obviously, it is a Science Fiction rather than a fantasy adventure—although buildings and bunkers to be found in the scenario could lend it the description of being a Science Fiction ‘dungeon bash’, but the puzzles and traps to found on Level Zero of the Starship Warden are less random and less arbitrary, and there is not the feeling that there is with S1, Tomb of Horrors that the Game Master—and thus E. Gary Gygax—is trying to kill his players’ characters. Lastly, where the title of S1, Tomb of Horrors suggested that as a scenario it was a combination of horror and fantasy, and was not, the title of Doom on the Warden does not suggest that it is a combination of Science Fiction and horror, but actually is. Doom on the Warden takes its Player Characters from megalophobia to nyctophobia to triskaidekaphobia to phobophobia to simply a sense of quiet dread…

Whether through discovery of their own or learning of it through a myth or legend, perhaps imparted by a tribal shaman, Doom on the Warden begins with the Player Characters at the entrance to ‘heaven’, an engineering hatch through which rises a great chimney, ascending to the home of the Ancients. Inside they discover several bodies of the Ancients—perhaps cast out of Heaven?—and as the chimney turns into a walkway, the Player Characters find themselves seemingly in a land of the giants, a forest of Brobdingnagian proportions, filled with giant trees, hornets the size of fists, and beasts such as rabbits and squirrels large enough to become beasts of burden. As with other levels on the Warden, Level Zero is a large oval shape, approximately eighteen miles across from the bow to the stern and fourteen miles from port to starboard. The level is divided into three concentric ovals or zones, working inward, a forest of giant willows, a berry plantations laid out with patches of mutant berries, and extensive flower gardens full of glens of mutated flowers, each one of different character and invoking a different sense of fear. There are plenty of encounters to be had in each of these zones, depending upon the direction in the Player Characters want to explore. They are free to wander and there is a table of random encounters included for each zone. Most of these encounters will either be dangerous or hostile, but there are plenty which are not and many of these are quite lightly done, adding an element of humour and roleplaying which nicely contrasts with the dangers and hostilities to be found elsewhere. One thing that the Player Characters will discover is that there is something or someone at work on the level—forestry robots work the forests, others work to restore the damage done by the catastrophe centuries ago, and there are transport devices readily and willing to ferry the Player Characters onward.

Ultimately, the Player Characters should make their way to the centre of the level and the island in the centre of Blume Lake—the latter a nod to the brothers who were early investors and co-owners of TSR, Inc. The island is home to a bunker, a place of the Ancients, and clearly an important one. Numerous robots protect it, but whatever intelligence is at work on the Level, it seems to want help… The final scenes of Doom on the Warden will see the Player Characters either save the Starship Warden or…?

Doom on the Warden is a difficult and challenging adventure. There are numerous encounters which will kill the Player Characters, a few simply by design, many through a player’s foolishness, but most through luck and the roll of the dice. As they proceed across this secret level, the players and their characters will be rewarded if their play is both careful and intelligent—and not just in terms of their characters’ survival, for there are plenty of artefacts and equipment to be scavenged too.

There are two ways in which Doom on the Warden can be run. One is as part of an ongoing campaign, the author suggesting that it be run as the midpoint of such a campaign. By that time, the players and their characters should have accumulated plenty of playing experience of Metamorphosis Alpha and the Starship Warden, as well as their characters having collected numerous artefacts, devices, and weapons of the Ancients. Even then, Doom on the Warden may be too challenging a scenario and its degree of lethality too high, such that it may even be a campaign-ending scenario. If so, it might be better off run towards the end of a campaign, or even as the culmination of campaign, more so because if the Player Characters are successful, the scenario sets the campaign and the Starship Warden in a wholly new (old) direction.

The other way of running the Doom on the Warden is as a tournament scenario much as S1 Tomb of Horrors was originally intended. This is run as a more linear scenario, rather than allowing the Player Characters the freedom to roam, the aim being to get them to Blume Lake and the bunker on the island at its centre. As well as advice on running the scenario, the author includes three sets of different pre-generated Player Characters and their motivations for exploring Level Zero aboard the Starship Warden. For the purposes of tournament play, each of the three groups of pre-generated Player Characters begin play with more knowledge about Level Zero than they would if the scenario is being as part of an ongoing campaign. The first group consists of Pure Strain Humans, members of the Vigilist tribe which dates back to the original Metamorphosis Alpha campaign run by James Ward. The Vigilists and their village were created by E. Gary Gygax and their inclusion is a nice tribute to him alongside the author being inspired by S1 Tomb of Horrors. The aim of the Vigilists is to ascend to Heaven and restore the Starship Warden to its original course. The second group consists of Wolfoids from Epsilon City—as detailed in the supplement of the same name—and like the Pure Strain Humans, their aim on Level Zero is to take control of the ship. Lastly, the third group consists of Mutants, drawn from across multiple levels of the Starship Warden, who also want to take control of the ship, primarily to deny control to the Pure Strain Humans. Almost a fifth of Doom on the Warden is dedicated to character sheets for the three different groups. They consist of eight Mutant, one Pure Strain Human, and six Wolfoid pre-generated character sheets, there being just the one Pure Strain Human character sheet because they are easy to roll up in comparison to Mutants and Wolfoids. Lastly, Doom on the Warden includes three pre-generated Player Characters inspired by backers of the Kickstarter.

Physically, at just forty-eight pages, Doom on the Warden is a nicely presented hardback. Both writing and editing are decent and as you would expect from a title from Goodman Games, the range of artwork is excellent. In particular, Peter Mullen’s double-page spreads inside the front and back covers really capture the scope and scale of the Starship Warden. They, like much of the artwork can be used as handouts when running Doom on the Warden.

If there is an issue with Doom on the Warden, it is perhaps that it is difficult to use, that it has the potential to end a campaign. That though is by design and by inspiration, S1 Tomb of Horrors itself suffering from both issues. Fortunately, Doom on the Warden is very much less arbitrary in its play and its design than S1 Tomb of Horrors. If there is anything missing from Doom on the Warden, it is a gallery of its artwork which the Game Master can use as handouts for her players. 

Doom on the Warden is a fantastic scenario. It is big, it is nasty, it is dangerous, and it has the scope to either end a campaign, whether as a Total Party Kill or as the culmination of an ongoing campaign, or set both campaign and the Starship Warden on a wholly new (old) course. It lives up to its inspiration, S1 Tomb of Horrors, but goes beyond it to have the Player Characters’ actions have an effect upon Level Zero of the Starship Warden, on the Starship Warden itself, and on the campaign, and is better for it. Doom on the Warden is deadly and if the Player Characters are not careful or smart, they will get killed, but not necessarily in as arbitrary a fashion as S1 Tomb of Horrors. Which means that if the Player Characters can succeed and overcome the challenges presented in Doom on the Warden, then both they and their players truly have the right to feel a sense of great accomplishment.

Miskatonic Monday #59: The Posse

 Between October 2003 and October 2013, Chaosium, Inc. published a series of books for Call of Cthulhu under the Miskatonic University Library Association brand. Whether a sourcebook, scenario, anthology, or campaign, each was a showcase for their authors—amateur rather than professional, but fans of Call of Cthulhu nonetheless—to put forward their ideas and share with others. The programme was notable for having launched the writing careers of several authors, but for every Cthulhu Invictus, The Pastores, Primal State, Ripples from Carcosa, and Halloween Horror, there was a Five Go Mad in Egypt, Return of the Ripper, Rise of the Dead, Rise of the Dead II: The Raid, and more...

The Miskatonic University Library Association brand is no more, alas, but what we have in its stead is the Miskatonic Repository, based on the same format as the DM’s Guild for Dungeons & Dragons. It is thus, “...a new way for creators to publish and distribute their own original Call of Cthulhu content including scenarios, settings, spells and more…” To support the endeavours of their creators, Chaosium has provided templates and art packs, both free to use, so that the resulting releases can look and feel as professional as possible. To support the efforts of these contributors, Miskatonic Monday is an occasional series of reviews which will in turn examine an item drawn from the depths of the Miskatonic Repository.

—oOo—

Name: The Posse

Publisher: Chaosium, Inc.
Author: Andy Miller

Setting: Down Darker Trails

Product: Scenario
What You Get: thirty-four page, 29.29 MB Full Colour PDF
Elevator Pitch: Cowboys and dinosaurs, oh my! (Again)
Plot Hook: The Boyd Gang has robbed the 11:10 to Santaquin! Let’s ride out and round ‘em up.

Plot Support: Introduction to train robberies, five NPCs, six detailed pregenerated Investigators, NPC and Investigator portraits.

Production Values: Decent.

Pros
# Cowboys and dinosaurs, oh my!

# Sequel to The Last Valley
# Potential convention scenario
# Potential one-shot

# Well done pregenerated Investigators
# Enjoyable introduction to the Lost Worlds genre

# Straightforward plot
# Multiple set-ups

# Classic Wild West set-up

# Action driven scenario

Cons
# Linear plot
# Utah background underused

# Requires The Last Valley

# No Sanity losses for failure?

Conclusion
# Cowboys and dinosaurs, oh my!
# Classic Wild West set-up

# Linear plot

Miskatonic Monday #57: The Last Valley

Between October 2003 and October 2013, Chaosium, Inc. published a series of books for Call of Cthulhu under the Miskatonic University Library Association brand. Whether a sourcebook, scenario, anthology, or campaign, each was a showcase for their authors—amateur rather than professional, but fans of Call of Cthulhu nonetheless—to put forward their ideas and share with others. The programme was notable for having launched the writing careers of several authors, but for every Cthulhu Invictus, The Pastores, Primal State, Ripples from Carcosa, and Halloween Horror, there was a Five Go Mad in Egypt, Return of the Ripper, Rise of the Dead, Rise of the Dead II: The Raid, and more...

The Miskatonic University Library Association brand is no more, alas, but what we have in its stead is the Miskatonic Repository, based on the same format as the DM’s Guild for Dungeons & Dragons. It is thus, “...a new way for creators to publish and distribute their own original Call of Cthulhu content including scenarios, settings, spells and more…” To support the endeavours of their creators, Chaosium has provided templates and art packs, both free to use, so that the resulting releases can look and feel as professional as possible. To support the efforts of these contributors, Miskatonic Monday is an occasional series of reviews which will in turn examine an item drawn from the depths of the Miskatonic Repository.

—oOo—

Name: The Last Valley

Publisher: Chaosium, Inc.
Author: Andy Miller

Setting: Down Darker Trails

Product: Scenario
What You Get: forty-two page, 36.18 MB Full Colour PDF
Elevator Pitch: Cowboys and dinosaurs, oh my!
Plot Hook: Lost in swirling fog in 1870s Utah whilst hunted by unknowable monsters from the past.

Plot Support: Detailed Utah background and history, three monsters (dinosaurs), two NPCs, two maps, six handouts/pictures, and six pregenerated Investigators.

Production Values: Decent enough, but could have been better organised.

Pros
# Cowboys and dinosaurs, oh my!
# Potential convention scenario
# Potential one-shot

# Well done pregenerated Investigators
# Enjoyable introduction to the Lost Worlds genre

# Solid background to Utah
# Creepy, fog-bound hunt

# It can happen to Arkham, it can happen to Utah

# Action driven scenario

# Potential to divert a campaign in a weird direction

Cons
# Linear
# Utah background underused

# Maps difficult to use

# No Sanity losses for failure?

# Potential to derail a campaign in a weird direction

Conclusion
# Cowboys and dinosaurs, oh my!
# Maps and Utah difficult to use

# Potential to derail a campaign in a weird direction

Miskatonic Monday #56: The Room with No Doors

Between October 2003 and October 2013, Chaosium, Inc. published a series of books for Call of Cthulhu under the Miskatonic University Library Association brand. Whether a sourcebook, scenario, anthology, or campaign, each was a showcase for their authors—amateur rather than professional, but fans of Call of Cthulhu nonetheless—to put forward their ideas and share with others. The programme was notable for having launched the writing careers of several authors, but for every Cthulhu Invictus, The Pastores, Primal State, Ripples from Carcosa, and Halloween Horror, there was a Five Go Mad in Egypt, Return of the Ripper, Rise of the Dead, Rise of the Dead II: The Raid, and more...

The Miskatonic University Library Association brand is no more, alas, but what we have in its stead is the Miskatonic Repository, based on the same format as the DM’s Guild for Dungeons & Dragons. It is thus, “...a new way for creators to publish and distribute their own original Call of Cthulhu content including scenarios, settings, spells and more…” To support the endeavours of their creators, Chaosium has provided templates and art packs, both free to use, so that the resulting releases can look and feel as professional as possible. To support the efforts of these contributors, Miskatonic Monday is an occasional series of reviews which will in turn examine an item drawn from the depths of the Miskatonic Repository.

—oOo—

Name: The Room with No Doors

Publisher: Chaosium, Inc.
Author: M. T. Black

Setting: Classic Jazz Age Arkham

Product: Scenario
What You Get: Twenty-eight page, 6.5 MB Full Colour PDF
Elevator Pitch: What would drive a housewife to a murderous mania?
Plot Hook: A landlord hires the Investigators to look into the truth of her new property being haunted.

Plot Support: Detailed background, a decent floorplan, nine handouts, and a single monster.

Production Values: Clean and tidy, well organised, clear map, and nicely done handouts.

Pros
# Classic Call of Cthulhu haunted house scenario
# Potential convention scenario
# Potential one-shot

# Superb handouts
# Easily adapted to other periods

# Investigation path clearly laid out
# Mythos light

# Nice ties to Arkham

# Possible first encounter with the Mythos?

Cons
# Classic Call of Cthulhu haunted house scenario
# Mythos light

# Too obvious a title

# Too close to ‘The Haunting’ from the Call of Cthulhu, Seventh Edition Quick-Start Rules

Conclusion
# Great production values
# Classic Call of Cthulhu haunted house scenario

# Too obvious a title and set-up for experienced players